AG016 and AG031 pics

[Kuki]

Back in October, I got permission from Maverick Nate and TTEchidna to change the head pictures for AG016 and AG031, and based them on major events and dub titles. Pikastorm claims I didn't so he reverted them. AG016 was about Roxanne and Ash's battle, not about a Geodude using Rock Smash. The dub title for AG031 was "Just One of The Geysers", and my pic had Machop using Cross Chop on a Geyser. Wouldn't you say mine are better?

 

[Sketch]

Let me see all the images in question.

 

[sailorsailormoon]

Back in October, I got permission from Maverick Nate and TTEchidna to change the head pictures for AG016 and AG031, and based them on major events and dub titles. Pikastorm claims I didn't so he reverted them. AG016 was about Roxanne and Ash's battle, not about a Geodude using Rock Smash. The dub title for AG031 was "Just One of The Geysers", and my pic had Machop using Cross Chop on a Geyser. Wouldn't you say mine are better?

"Just One of The Geysers" image

It doesn't count "dub title for AG031 was Just One of The Geysers".

The first one is better

 

[Kuki]

Well dub titles are allowed to be a basis for the pic, like EP092. As for AG016, the battle is what the episode is about, so that one should be fine

 

[Sketch]

I'd rather use the Hariyama image. Get a higher quality of that.

 

[Maverick Nate]

And png! All episode head images are to be png's from now on. They are better quality and will be much easier to deal with when we get them all done.

 

[Kuki]

But the point is Pikastorm didn't get permission, while I did, and cosidering Pikastorm gave no reason, this is totally unfair to me.

 

[Sketch]

To be honest, neither of your pictures are good.

For AG16, get something with Nosepass or something...he's in both titles.

For AG31, the picture being used now is better.

"It's not fair to me." Well your situation hasn't been fair to a lot of us, so cut your losses and move on.

 

[FabuVinny]

As I said in your last thread on the AG031 image:

An episode picture needs to represent the episode's plot in some way. This should be the priority over the dub title (especially as the Japanese version has a different title). In this case, the current image is satisfactory as it represents the Gym battle.

Honestly, your reasons against the first picture can be used against the one you support for the second. Just as AG016 isn't about a Geodude using Rock Smash, AG031 isn't about a Machop using Cross Chop. The first AG031 picture is better because it actually represents the Gym battle.