• The forums' spoiler embargo for all content from Pokémon Legends: Z-A's Mega Dimension DLC has been lifted! Feel free to talk about the new content from the expansion across the forums without the need of spoiler tabs!

    Please note that this lifted embargo only applies for the forums, and may still be in effect on other Bulbagarden sites.

Ashs Oshawott vs Ashs Palpitoad

Who wins

  • Oshawott

    Votes: 2 18.2%

  • Palpitoad

    Votes: 9 81.8%
  • Total voters
    11
Gotta go with my bro Palpitoad. He is always decent every time he shows up and doesn't suffer from the inconsistency syndrome like a certain little otter.
 
Palpitoad would sweep that Osha before it manages to push Pikachu into the battle :D
 
Palpitoad I think, because Oshawott is too inconsistent. While Palpitoad had way to little screentime and has been portrayed as a mediocre battler (winning some and losing some battles, all not very spectacular battles), Oshawott is just... weird. One episode he comes off as very strong and able to take stronger opponents, in another episode, like the Cheren one, he acts like a total nitwit, easily defeated by a Herdier due to his own faults.

And looking at their current movesets, I think Palpitoad has the advantage too.
 
As much as i despise the wanker, mijumaru would win vs palpitoad. He even single handedly beaten the toad in his capture ep.
 
Mr. Blaze said:
Palpitoad I think, because Oshawott is too inconsistent. While Palpitoad had way to little screentime and has been portrayed as a mediocre battler (winning some and losing some battles, all not very spectacular battles), Oshawott is just... weird. One episode he comes off as very strong and able to take stronger opponents, in another episode, like the Cheren one, he acts like a total nitwit, easily defeated by a Herdier due to his own faults.

And looking at their current movesets, I think Palpitoad has the advantage too.
Click to expand...

Lmfao, what episode was this?? Mijumaru and super strong should NEVER be used in the same sentence.
 
1rkhachatryan said:
Mr. Blaze said:
Palpitoad I think, because Oshawott is too inconsistent. While Palpitoad had way to little screentime and has been portrayed as a mediocre battler (winning some and losing some battles, all not very spectacular battles), Oshawott is just... weird. One episode he comes off as very strong and able to take stronger opponents, in another episode, like the Cheren one, he acts like a total nitwit, easily defeated by a Herdier due to his own faults.

And looking at their current movesets, I think Palpitoad has the advantage too.
Click to expand...

Lmfao, what episode was this?? Mijumaru and super strong should NEVER be used in the same sentence.
Click to expand...
Well okay, I should've used different words. At least he was shown to be relatively good in some episodes, being able to take stronger opponents, be it evolved Pokémon or Pokémon with a type advantage.
 
Mr. Blaze said:
1rkhachatryan said:
Mr. Blaze said:
Palpitoad I think, because Oshawott is too inconsistent. While Palpitoad had way to little screentime and has been portrayed as a mediocre battler (winning some and losing some battles, all not very spectacular battles), Oshawott is just... weird. One episode he comes off as very strong and able to take stronger opponents, in another episode, like the Cheren one, he acts like a total nitwit, easily defeated by a Herdier due to his own faults.

And looking at their current movesets, I think Palpitoad has the advantage too.
Click to expand...

Lmfao, what episode was this?? Mijumaru and super strong should NEVER be used in the same sentence.
Click to expand...
Well okay, I should've used different words. At least he was shown to be relatively good in some episodes, being able to take stronger opponents, be it evolved Pokémon or Pokémon with a type advantage.
Click to expand...

One episode. The only episode he won a battle without BS was against Krokorok.
 
1rkhachatryan said:
Mr. Blaze said:
1rkhachatryan said:
Mr. Blaze said:
Palpitoad I think, because Oshawott is too inconsistent. While Palpitoad had way to little screentime and has been portrayed as a mediocre battler (winning some and losing some battles, all not very spectacular battles), Oshawott is just... weird. One episode he comes off as very strong and able to take stronger opponents, in another episode, like the Cheren one, he acts like a total nitwit, easily defeated by a Herdier due to his own faults.

And looking at their current movesets, I think Palpitoad has the advantage too.
Click to expand...

Lmfao, what episode was this?? Mijumaru and super strong should NEVER be used in the same sentence.
Click to expand...
Well okay, I should've used different words. At least he was shown to be relatively good in some episodes, being able to take stronger opponents, be it evolved Pokémon or Pokémon with a type advantage.
Click to expand...

One episode. The only episode he won a battle without BS was against Krokorok.
Click to expand...
I'm not saying in any way Oshawott is strong overall (I said, "In one episode it appears strong" (not meaning one particular episode, but certain episodes in which he won battles), but overall, I'd say Oshawott is one of Ash's weaker Pokémon). He has been shown to be able to win battles, yet lose in a ridiculous way in others. Writers' fault, they know Oshawott is popular and try to use this by making it do "funny things", yet they also know Oshawott needs to win some battles too, to be "believable".

Are we done?
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom