CSS Design Vs Tables

Status
Not open for further replies.

Doctor Oak

Can't Touch Dis.
Joined
Jul 19, 2004
Messages
2,757
Reaction score
3
Ahh, the fabled battle of the top-two duo of Web design. On one corner you have CSS Design - one implimented in a more accurate sense of design and one that's easily customisable at that.

In the other you have the more widely used, more comptable and more easy to code tabular design.

Both have their big faults and benefits of course. Table design's biggest one being that it's simple to throw together and does the job - in all browsers 99% accurate to the design. CSS, however, is more professional feeling when done right and fully customisable at any time. On the other hand, Tabular design does have it's faults and is not the ideal solution to web-design. Whilst CSS design throws up incompatabilty problems largely due to IE's pathetic backwardness.

What is the most used by webmasters here and what are your opinions on either/both?

My own are that Pokecharms is currently a tabular design site with CSS used pretty much solely for the basic colour-scheme at present. The main reason for this was A) Getting the damn layout finished and operational after farting about for months desigining one and B) the fact I couldn't be arsed fiddling around trying to fix incompatability issues for months afterwards.

With big changes to the site over the summer though, a new layout calls and a further push towards CSS Design comes. Just how far that push is and what it's result will be will remain to be seen I guess.

Excuse the possible crappy nature of this post BTW - i'm tired and not getting any sleep recently. It's not too good for your writing skills. ^^
 
I have yet to really take the time and learn how to design with CSS, so I've stuck with tables as far as I can remember. Not to mention they're what ImageReady kicks out...

At the current time, with IE's lack of support, I don't see a reason to use CSS for full layouts, half of the time something will go wrong and it'll go "BOOM!"
 
All the layouts I've made have been tabular. I've experimented with CSS design, but you really don't want to see the end results. XD
 
Floating CSS boxes!

*wishes CSS would have better dynamic layout capabilities*
 
I'll put it like this--if you haven't gotten CSS design to work right, you're not trying hard enough.

I don't know how I ever designed without it. It makes things so easy to modify and set up.

Now, I will admit that I still used tables up until very recently. But I put my mind to setting up a site entirely with CSS, and so (on the school's time :p) I set up a new website for the school-owned computer shop without a single table! All it needs now is content, and I'm not taking the class next year. Fortunately, I set it up so the next classes shouldn't have much trouble with it.

Tables are too rigid and too difficult to work with. I realize that now that I've become adjusted to CSS.

Besides, CSS has given us quite possibly the greatest addition to (X)HTML ever: the style:

<span style="color:[HASHTAG]#fff[/HASHTAG];background:[HASHTAG]#f00[/HASHTAG];font:bold 16px arial,helvetica,sans-serif;">Text</span>

Without CSS, you'd have to code a whole table just for the background, plus you'd have to set up a long font tag for the fonts, and <strong> tag (or <b> if you're lazy) for the bold.

I'm sure some of you know this, but I'm sure that others don't, so don't jump on me for that.

- Trip
 
CSS + DIVs... >>;

I don't think my layout is based on tables =/ I just use CSS for the links and stuff. XD
 
tabular design makes me cry. I feel sorry for the people who have to maintain it.

obviously I use CSS, although I'm slowly going insane working around Trident bugs.
 
I use tables =/

My last post really didn't specify XD I <3 my tables!
 
I'm trying to learn CSS to be able to do things like that. However, there are problems of compatibility between IEE and Ffox... sometimes I tried to do something new, it seemed to go perfect on Ffox and then checked IEE (I know I should do it the other direction, bur I just don't stand IEE)... I keep trying anyway ^_^U
 
IE has been known to really crap up CSS. Firefox does great with CSS, but won't work with nonstandard code like bordercolor or glow. But since 90% of Internet users still use Internet Exploder, you might have to fudge some of the code to work in IE.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom