Do u Believe that Game/Manga Battle Frontier is better then Anime's Battle frontier

[Hurricane Kishore]

Hello everybody
We already saw The anime Battle Frontier Saga
But the Anime Battle frontier was different from Game Battle Frontier while the Manga totally follow the Game
So here is the question, Do u like the Anime's Battle frontier or u wanted to see the Game Battle Frontier ?
I honestly like the Game Battle frontier, When I was reading the Manga's Platinum chapter I cried to myself thinking Why wasn't Ash Battle Frontier Journey As Cool as That ?
In the Anime, The Battle Frontier seem nothing more then a Advance Gym Battle. The only Difference is that By wining Gym battle A trainer can qualify to enter a League & by wining the League a trainer can challenge the E4 & champion But by wining Battle frontier all a trainer get is a offer to become one of them
Scott say's Battle Frontier Purpose is too Present Pokemon Battle as a Art But I don't get by some indoor battle what kind of a freaking art does it create ?
It seem only seem that Battle Dome fulfill its purposh while In other BF only the Challenger company witness the Battle
The Game/ Manga is way better. The coolest part is not just the fact that each facility has different rule but also U have to collect point by battling other challenger in order to face the frontier head
But since all Facility situated together it seem more meaningful for it's purpose then the anime
I not sure but if Writer have another Battle Frontier saga then I hope he make it like the game rather then turning it into a version of Gym battle

 

[Aestivate]

Re: Do u Believe that Game/Manga Battle Frontier is better then Anime's Battle fronti

Moving to GF.

 

[MizuTaipu]

Re: Do u Believe that Game/Manga Battle Frontier is better then Anime's Battle fronti

The game version, since Satoshi never did all of the challenges that the facilities in the game version provided.

 

[Almonds]

Re: Do u Believe that Game/Manga Battle Frontier is better then Anime's Battle fronti

I prefer the game and the manga. For one thing, Lucy was a little too OOC in the anime.

 

[Eitarou]

Re: Do u Believe that Game/Manga Battle Frontier is better then Anime's Battle fronti

Which manga? There's more than one.

Knowing the internet, I'll assume you mean Pokemon Adventures.

But yes, the anime version was nothing more than glorified Gym battles.

I wanted to see the challenges and was extremely disappointed when they didn't happen.

So Game/Pokemon Adventures wins.

 

[Cybersai]

Re: Do u Believe that Game/Manga Battle Frontier is better then Anime's Battle fronti

Its weird that the writers just had Ash go to battle the Brains immediately instead of doing the challenges before.

The Battle Tube could have been really interesting in the anime.

 

[Ravarian]

Re: Do u Believe that Game/Manga Battle Frontier is better then Anime's Battle fronti

The game version. Nothing really to say about the manga versions but the anime version irked me a fair bit.

Frontier Brains are supposed to be several notches ABOVE the everyday Gym Leader, anime writers... And giving Tucker, Greta and Lucy only one episode while the first Gym Leader of Sinnoh appeared in and had roles in six rubbed me the wrong way.

As well as the personalities, Anabel and Lucy in particular were OOC, and I liked them better in the games.

 

[Almonds]

Re: Do u Believe that Game/Manga Battle Frontier is better then Anime's Battle fronti

The game's are much better because of the better chemistry in the games