Gold Silver and Crystal Remakes?

[Krucifier]

Should Nintendo bother...? if they do would YOU buy them?

 

[bell02+]

I thought the Pokedex was already completed... but I'll buy them (on the GBA). Right now I don't want anything to touch Diamond and Pearl's development though. I really want the game to be as perfect as it can be, and I really hope the game expands to old territories, making the game even longer.

However, we don't need a crystal, they can just combine crystal with both of them (adding in Animations).

 

[Kem]

No. I thought they were fine in their original form. They should work on new games rather than reviving old ones.

 

[Misty]

No. I thought they were fine in their original form. They should work on new games rather than reviving old ones.

Agreed. I'm sick of remakes, give me Diamond and Pearl.

 

[Another Fan]

But FR/LG were good to get new people into the franchise. So, it is good. Not bad. What better way that to bring back what got us into the franchise?

Technically, LG so far has been my only taste of this generation.

 

[tropius]

I think tht it would be cool to make remakes of gold and silver. it would get the people that are just getting into pokemon to the johto without spending grueling hours spending time to find the color versions. plus, they would be able to trade with FR/LG/R/S/E. i think that it would be kinda cool to make a remake of yellow too. it would be cool to start with pikachu on a new game.
but if they do, they really should wait to make it until diamond and pearl are finished and at least out on demo in america.

 

[Lil Brother]

Oh, come on, you would all buy the if they were remade.

I would like it, just after D/P comes out.

 

[Jukain]

Hmmm...I got FR because of having to go through the first gen again, with better graphics and the mechanics of Ru/Sa behind it, as well as the Sevii Islands. I wouldn't have gotten Emerald even if I had waited because I have Ruby and I hate redundancy. Emerald does have the greater majority of G/S/C's pokes and other features that make it one of the best pokemon games to have existed. True, I have Yellow, but for some reason, I ignored that in this case. It was like starting pokemon all over again for me, and this time, I would get it right, now having 5 years of experience. It amused me for quite a while. Would I get a remake of G/S/C? Possibly, if it was done as well as FR/LG, or perhaps better. For me, it would not depend on anything that was in the list. It would have to depend on how it is done.

Will they ever make these games? Probably not.

 

[Krucifier]

sure you can get some G/S/C pokemon in emerald, and from coloseum,pokemon XD, but you cant get all of them......i think.....

 

[Jukain]

There are enough second gen pokes between FR/LG and Emerald to account for them all.

 

[GreatLiver]

If theres gonna be a large gap in between D/P and what ever comes after a remake might not be bad, but not any time soon

 

[Nekusagi]

It'd be nice. As long as we got a bonus area, like Sevii Islands in FRLG and BF in Emerald (and no, Depressing Kanto does *not* count), and they made it an otherwise exact port, it would rock.

Weren't some people working on an Advance-style remake emulator (for GBA ROMs) some time ago?

 

[Trainer Lisa]

Yes, they should definitely have remakes of Gold, Silver, and Crystal!!

I LOVED those games!!!! ^_^

That would be so awesome......


Although, somehow, I don't think they'd actually go to all the trouble to have remakes of those games when they still haven't made a remake of Pokemon Yellow (which happens to be my favorite Pokemon game). :-(

 

[paperfairy]

Agreed. I'm sick of remakes, give me Diamond and Pearl.

D/P first, THEN a G/S remake.

G/S/C was awesome tho. Good times~ :-D

 

[Ash_Pokemaster]

I agree. Even though I'm sick of waiting DP to realease and a 4-year-period has past since the last "new-story/pokemon" tranditional games were released, I would agree the DP to release and after 1 or 2 years let us see Gold and Silver remakes. That's a possible scenario anyway... Since after Ruby and Sapphire FireRed and LeafGreen released.. I mean Nintendo MUST give new trainers the chance to ge thte expierience of Gold and Silver (which in my opinion were the best of the masterpieces in Pokemon Games). Probably something like GoldenSun or SilverMoon would be right.

 

[Eszett]

For this to be even a remote possibility, I would expect that Diamond and Pearl will need to have been around for quite some time and the people growing a trifle restless over having done everything within the games. Not only that, but in addition all of the third-generation games would need to be discontinued or otherwise allocated to the Best Sellers list of marked-down games before they insist on pushing forward a Gold/Silver remake. It's not exactly a wise business practice to offer something in a game that can already be had by purchasing another game.

Overall, as much as I would love to see Johto revitalized, I cannot see it happening given the circumstances.

 

[Kijuna]

GSC really needs a remake. I miss the plains outside of Ecruteak, and the underground passages of Goldenrod, and the forest at the foot of Mt. Silver, and the lighthouse, and all the gym leaders, and working together with Lance to take down Team Rocket. Johto was so awesome, and without all the constraints of the Gameboy, and adding the dark types to a reasonable area, they could be the best games ever.

All for it, and it might happen in a few years.

 

[RBYGSCRSFRLGEPD]

Kijuna, would you be happy if Johto was included in Pearl and Diamond? (I hope they do--but it'll be enough trouble fitting every Pokémon onto there...)

Personally, I'm somewhat against simply a remake of GSC, like FRLG. I would rather have a Johto-based original game. Somewhat difficult to pull off, but I would enjoy it much more than a remake. Perhaps this is because I just replayed my Gold, until a week ago when its saving died...may it rest in peace.

 

[Openjer-D-Minus]

Meh.....i'd rather get Diamand and Pearl. Only cause they look good.....speaking of which, who knows what regin Diamand and Pearl is in?

 

[GreatLiver]

It's called Shin-Oh but seeing how the graphics aren't that advanced it may include more than just the new region