Harry Potter Saga vs. Twilight Saga

[Continent Turtle]

I saw no thread for this, so... here it is.

What's your opinion on the saga's? Which is the best? Would Harry win from Edward? Would Jacob crush Hagrid? Would Hagrid tame the wolf pack? Your opinion please!

I vote Harry Potter btw.
hew:

 

[Hector]

One is written by an author that actually has talent. The other is nothing more than the fantasies of a bored housewife.

Picked Potter naturally.

 

[Proxima Centauri B]

Potter. Harry Potter is extremely well written and though out, I actually love the Twilight books, but they are no where near the level of the Harry Potter saga. Stephanie Meyer had a good concept, but it ended up being a lovey dovey romantic thing that wasnt as good as it is hyped up to be.

 

[Buzz]

Harry Potter follows the grand adventure of a young man discovering and expanding his magical horizons while completing the goal of the entire Wizarding World to defeat the Death Eaters and save the entire world from Lord Voldemort's wrath as the Chosen One.

Twilight is about a girl who loves a vampire that sparkles but is in a love triangle with a werewolf with abs.

 

[LuxrayOfTheWild]

Harry Potter is definatley the answer. The series is well written, the plot was wonderfully put together, it's full of surprises, and unlike Twilight it has a much wider target demographic(I feel as if Twilight mainly is targeted towards teenage girls, while Harry Potter is targeted towards mostly children and teens of both genders.)

 

[Insanish Danish]

OMG. Harry Potter...no question at all.

Harry Potter is a beautiful and imaginative world with wonderful characters and an amazing story. When you're reading one of the books, or watching one of the movies, you're just so swept away by the magic that you wish you could be there alongside Harry and his friends as a student at Hogwarts, joining them in the fight versus good and evil.

Twilight has a flat and irritating protagonist, a flat and irritating love interest, flat and irritating side characters, and no real plot aside from "So there's this guy and I love him but he's a vampire and we can't be together because he could potentially kill me but I love him so much despite hardly talking to him and he's so beautiful but it's too dangerous ah screw it I'm having sex with him." Oh, and occasionally some other vampire wants to drink her blood. And she has a werewolf who's in love with her. Yeah, no. Harry Potter FTW.

 

[Karamazov]

I do hate Twilight, but that's not why I'm picking Harry Potter. Harry Potter is just more imaginative, and the interesting world and engaging characters just suck you in.