HG and SS sister game?

B

BlueNostalgia

Impossible is only a word
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
463
Reaction score
1
Gold and Silver had crystal, but in the remakes of R/B/Y they didn't make a remake of yellow.

Do you think they'll do it with Crystal? And if so, how will it be different, what will it be called etc?
 
No! Please, please, please do not start this up again. We've already had this debate. Please let it die.
 
Before Gen 5 was announced, I'd say it was a possibility. Now it obviously isn't going to happen.
 
Oh God, come on. How much more proof do you need, that it WILL NOT happen? Like Ryuu said, theres already a whole debate about this in the HGSS forum.
 
Ryuutakesh! said:
No! Please, please, please do not start this up again. We've already had this debate. Please let it die.
Click to expand...

This, it's probably not going to happen, ever, stop beating a dead horse and stop making topics about it people. D;

Also, OP, you could have just posted in a pre-existing thread (or are they locked or something?)
 
MrMuggles said:
Gold and Silver had crystal, but in the remakes of R/B/Y they didn't make a remake of yellow.

Do you think they'll do it with Crystal? And if so, how will it be different, what will it be called etc?
Click to expand...
You got HeartGold and SoulSilver, remaking Crystal would be a third game with the EXACT SAME SHIT. How are you people unable to comprehend that is beyond me. There is no Crystal remake and there will NEVER be one, let it go.
 
Dear sweet gawd... it's NEVER gonna happen. And to this day I STILL don't see how people were thinking of this even before Gen V was announced. They never did this when they made FireRed and LeafGreen, why do it now? I don't care how popular HG/SS is, actually.... that popularity right there should be more than enough to where a Crystal remake isn't needed. Go ahead, bash me about that, I don't care anymore... I got hounded on for disagreeing about a MindCrystal being made once before, I just don't care anymore.

Here's the thing... Crystal and Yellow were essentially "enhanced remakes" on their own. That's what all the 3rd versions are, "enhanced remakes" of the original 2. Does it REALLY make sense to make a remake of a remake? I bet $50 that people are gonna be saying that a remake of Emerald and a remake of Platinum's next...*facepalms* and when THAT happens, I'll be leaving the forum for a few weeks when it all blows over...
 
was announced. They never did this when they made FireRed and LeafGreen, why do it now?
Click to expand...

Because one set of remakes hardly sets the standard on how things will be, its no proof that things will be the same in future.

The only thing we haven't had confirmed is that what is next is definatly a Gen V as no official source has said "Fifth gen", other than that, I can say I doubt a third version and always have.
 
Shinx3000 said:
Because one set of remakes hardly sets the standard on how things will be, its no proof that things will be the same in future.

The only thing we haven't had confirmed is that what is next is definatly a Gen V as no official source has said "Fifth gen", other than that, I can say I doubt a third version and always have.
Click to expand...

Does GF and Pokemon company call them generations, or is this a fan term?
 
Shinx3000 said:
Because one set of remakes hardly sets the standard on how things will be, its no proof that things will be the same in future.
Click to expand...

True, but since HG/SS has features from the original Crystal there REALLY is no reason for a Crystal remake. And another reason that I brought up previously:

KPTitan said:
Here's the thing... Crystal and Yellow were essentially "enhanced remakes" on their own. That's what all the 3rd versions are, "enhanced remakes" of the original 2. Does it REALLY make sense to make a remake of a remake?
Click to expand...
 
HG/SS added all the features from Yellow and Crystal and tied the loop to complete updating of the first two gens. The end.
 
No, we need a tread where everybody can say why a Crystal remake won't be made.
 
Since the MindCrystal speculation thread in the HG/SS forum has been closed for obvious reasons, I think this one needs to be as well... Gen V's coming sometime this year whether some people like it or not, it's too late now for a Crystal remake.
 
Though, there is potential for the Crystal remake later on in 2025 or something like that, when the DS becomes the new Gameboy.
 
Like everyone else said, this ain't happening. (Some of) Crystal's features have been integrated into HG/SS.
 
Please note: The thread is from 16 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom