How can pokemons use field moves like Surf even when they fainted?

Almonds

Almonds

Lovely
Scorbunny Fan
Joined
Jul 12, 2011
Messages
14,622
Reaction score
4,578
I've been wondering about this for a very long time... but how can pokemons use field moves like Surf even when they fainted?

I mean - they FAINTED. They're unconscious. How can a fainted bird even carry you on its back and fly to the Pokemon Center?

I guess Sweet Scent doesn't really count because those pokemons usually smell good anyways, but moves like Rock Smash - they require MOVEMENT, and how do you expect a fainted pokemon to even move?
 
Usually when I think of a Pokemon fainting, I believe they run out of energy to fight but they have enough to use field moves. But it doesn't make sense that something like Piplup could take you across the ocean when it's fainted or a Pidgey could fly you to the other side of the region while fainted. I guess that is Pokemon logic.
 
I don't think that when a Pokemon has fainted, they are completely unconscious, it just means that they are too weak to fight. In the anime for example, after a Pokemon is claimed to be unable to fight, they wake up seconds later (if the damage isn't too bad).
I think that using a field move wouldn't take up as much energy as being in an actual battle, there isn't any opponent attacking them back.
That's what I believe anyways, thanks for reading.
 
Its purely game logic. Its to stop you getting stuck in a place that requires surf.
 
Surf: Sit on its fainted body.
Rock Smash: Whack it on the rock.
Cut: Use the claw as a machete.
Fly: Umm... NATURAL INSTINCT!
 
I always thought that 'fainted' really just meant 'rendered too weak to fight'.
 
Well, this is why you guys should all use Wailmer. Its blubbery body will float on the water even when unconscious, so you just throw the thing in the ocean, hop on, and paddle your way back to safety.
 
Karpi said:
Well, this is why you guys should all use Wailmer. Its blubbery body will float on the water even when unconscious, so you just throw the thing in the ocean, hop on, and paddle your way back to safety.
Click to expand...

Better Wailord. Not only because its size, but because according to its weight and estimated volume, the whale should be able to float on midair.


Ontopic, I agree with some people above, fainted Pokémon aren't unconscious, just unable to fight right now. Also, using field moves isn't the same as using them in the heat of a battle, and maybe that's why they don't consume PP on field.
 
It IS in fact a misnomer. The Japanese is ひんし which translates loosely to "almost dead", but basically implies that they are too weak to fight. Other translations go with "weakened" or similar.

They are not actually unconscious. Going with the "moves are techniques" idea, field moves are simply techinques that don't require much effort at all.

(Now, the applications of these, like swimming or cutting trees, that's kind of the same game logic that doesn't let you go up waist-height ledges or between thin trees)
 
...And that's why I always preferred O.O.C (out of combat) to Fainted as a term.
 
Aha, I always wondered about that! To be honest, I've always used "died" instead of "fainted." ._. I suppose because I didn't like that they were making it too "safe," so I just got into that habit... I never gave it much thought because of that, and just laugh at it sometimes when I had to use a fainted ("dead") Pokemon to surf. XD But now that I'm remembering fainted, I agree with some of you, it makes sense that they're just too weak to battle. XD
 
This was one of my first thoughts when I played pokemon. I got used to it eventually but I really don't think that there is a logical explanation behind it. I think that's just how the game works.
 
In video games, if a Pokémon fainted, it'll be considered "dead", but in the anime and manga, Pokémon fainting just mean that the Pokémon is injured, or its energy is completely depleted, but it's still not "dead" yet. After that, Pokémon will recover its energy automatically without any requirements, therefore it can use any HM moves after energy being recovered. Thus making Pokémon anime and manga more realistic than Pokémon video games. However, this energy recovery still applies to fainted Pokémon in games for HM purposes, but HP will not be recovered automatically.
 
I agree with everyone that's said that a Pokemon isn't fully unconscious when it "faints." Therefore, it should still be able to move and perform basic functions like swimming and flying.
 
Like this:

surfin___by_jhallpokemon-d32ebnh.png

In all seriousness, it's so you don't get stuck in an area if you happen to have knocked out a Pokémon with a necessary field move.
 
As some posters above said, I agree with the idea that "fainted" doesn't mean "knocked out". oAo
 
Dang it, I wanted to make a joke about this, but people already beat me to the punch.

How about this: to use fly, you just throw the fainted Pokemon like a paper airplane, and grab on!

Or, more seriously, we could go with what everyone else has said: That they're weak, but not knocked out.
 
Please note: The thread is from 13 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom