I have an absurd theory!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
P

pokemonmaniacSLR

New Member
Joined
May 5, 2009
Messages
17
Reaction score
0
okay this may sound realy obsered:
i was searching for the charecter looker when i came across his manga charecter and decided to have a look at the other manga charecters as i never read it(i have never read the pokemon manga properly)

it was the
pokemon diamand and pearl adventure!- manga

and they say the anime is based on manga right

well look at this http://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Category:Pokémon_DP_Adventure_characters
and look at the charecters: hareta,Kōya,Mitsumi and Kaisē

heres the questoin apart from the Kaisē charecter, what simularities do they have to the anime charecters?

you will be quite suprised

and then look at the kaise charecter to the hareta person what do you think?

could this be the answer (based on the manga) be what we are looking for?






(i am not saying ash is lucas or the manga is based on the anime all the time)
 
Last edited:
Re: i have an obsered theory!!

The only manga that really had any relevance to the manga was the electric tale of pikachu. Diamond and Pearl Adventure really has no hold on anything about the anime, so you're probably out of luck with that assumption.
 
Re: i have an obsered theory!!

i didnt mean that i just wanted to point out how that hareta guy has simular looks simular to ash
 
Well, the only thing I noticed that Ash has in common with Hareta is spiky hair, and the fact that they are both traveling with girls that have the same outfit.
 
I'm confused. I thought Ash's manga incarnation was Red? Of course, I don't follow the manga religiously, so I can't say anything about it nowadays. Am I missing something?
 
Yes, both the fact that there's many different manga series, and the fact that, with a couple exceptions (Electric Tale of Pikachu and the movie adaptions), the manga have nothing to do with the anime. They're all just different adaptions of the games.
 
Ah, I see. Thanks for clearing that up; I'll be ducking out quietly now. :p
 
ok let me tell it clearer

ok the link in the manga to the anime i got was that hareta,Kōya,Mitsumi

-in the anime llook simular to ash,dawn and paul

and what i was thinking cuz that hareta and kiase charecter are farther and son in the manga

and then i thought along these lines will they do tht in the anime?

now that is the obserd answer
 
...no.

The anime is not related to the manga. If you pay attention, you should know that they're both based off the video games. Ash is based off the protagonist for Red and Blue, and Hareta is based off the protagonist for Diamond and Pearl.

Also please learn to spell.
 
i do know the manga and anime arnt related-but maybe a point in the manga could also be used in the anime thats what im tryingto say

just a point not the whole relating thing,

i wish i didnt post this now u dont see what i see

i hope my theory is right ,but i cant realy say nothin more if u cant see my point

i am not saying the anime and manga are related and i know the anime is based on electric tales of pika chu

-this is a theary thats why i called it abserd or obserd

gee reali how many more times can i say it

-somebody out there plz, get my point:
 
speak english next time. I didn't understand that at all. Anime based of Manga? Not in the least. That is absurd.
 
pokemonmaniacSLR said:
i do know the manga and anime arnt related-but maybe a point in the manga could also be used in the anime thats what im tryingto say

just a point not the whole relating thing,

i wish i didnt post this now u dont see what i see

i hope my theory is right ,but i cant realy say nothin more if u cant see my point

i am not saying the anime and manga are related and i know the anime is based on electric tales of pika chu

-this is a theary thats why i called it abserd or obserd

gee reali how many more times can i say it

-somebody out there plz, get my point:
Click to expand...


No, Electric Tales Of Pikachu is based on the anime. Also, (not to sound mean) what was the theory? First, you said they were similar (I'm just a kid, but I'm pretty sure that's not a theory), but then you said a point in the manga could be used in the anime? Which one is it?

Edit:Ryuutakeshi beat me to the manga part.
 
pokemonmaniac, your theory is wrong. The manga and anime artists do not collaborate. They are all based off of the video games. That is all.

Closing this thread due to stupidity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom