• Our spoiler embargo for the non-DLC content for Pokémon Legends: Z-A is now lifted! Feel free to discuss the game freely across the forums without the need of spoiler tabs, and use content from the game within your profiles!

Iron Man Movie Review/Discussion Thread (Possible Spoilers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

GrnMarvl14

Lying
Joined
Jan 4, 2003
Messages
13,846
Reaction score
4
Saw it today. Loved it. Easily the best Marvel movie yet. The writing, the acting, and the directing melded together to create, by far, the best characters in any Marvel film so far. Robert Downey Jr. nailed Tony Stark PERFECTLY in every scene. From the cocky millionaire playboy to the man faced with the reality of what his life has been about and how he can bring about his own atonement. An early review I read of the film nailed it when they said that Robert Downey Jr's so good in this that he actually overshines his castmates, and I agree. Gwyneth Paltrow, Terrence Howard, and Jeff Bridges were all perfectly acted and written characters, but none of them got properly fleshed out (to the point where Jeff Bridges' Obadiah Stane turned into a stereotypical 2-dimensional villain in the final fight scene. C'mon..."I see you've upgraded your armor...AND SO HAVE I"? That's bad writing. But that was the ONLY bad part) and Jon Favreau's character doesn't get properly identified until the credits (if you know Iron Man's history, you know who he plays). You watch the movie and come out wishing there'd been more of it. Just to see these other characters as evolved as Tony Stark is.

The movie does several things extraordinarily well. From setting up possible sequels (Rhodes eyeing the MK II armor and saying "next time, baby", the terrorist group that kidnaps Stark being called the Ten Rings) to making the armor construction scenes feel integral and interesting (the first armor is built with a sense of imminent doom, and the subsequent armors are built with a comic bent as Stark is constantly hurting himself while being assisted by a couple of fairly primitive, albeit eager-to-please, robots) to the little touches that seem like nothing at first, but almost always pay off later in the movie (almost NOTHING happens without a later reason, down to a several off-hand comments).

And, as a comic geek, I was loving this movie from the beginning. From Stan Lee appearing to the entire terrorist setup (as I mentioned earlier, it sets up for a possible sequel, though I won't mention the most telling factors) to the SHIELD agents (and the great running gag where no one can remember what what their name is, culminating in the main agent saying "Just call us SHIELD") FINALLY bringing SHIELD into the modern Marvel movie (I THINK this is the only mention of them in ANY Marvel movie outside of MAYBE the Nick Fury made-for-TV movie from the 90s) to Jarvis (I'd have prefered Homer or Plato, but I got over it quickly) to the air force pilots being named Whiplash 1 and 2. And I'm sure I'm forgetting a few.

My only REAL complaint? The very last line spoken by Stark before the credits. I won't say what it is, but I can only hope that it's going to end up as much a joke as the eleven or so times he's said it in the comics.

And, if you see this movie, MAKE SURE YOU STAY PAST THE CREDITS. I was one of THREE people who remained past the credits (out of about...maybe 15 total in an early showing) and IT PAID OFF. Want to know what happens? Click the spoiler:

Fairly short scene with Samuel L. Jackson as Nick Fury telling Stark he wants to discuss the "Avengers Initiative."

All told, great movie. Great for comic fans. Great for techies. Great for people who just want to see a GOOD, VERY solid, movie.
 
Yeah I saw it yesterday and agree its ace. Apart from that last line, the only complaint I have is Rhodes's character, they'd said previously in interviews that they wanted to make him more of a straightlaced military guy to hold a sort of banter with stark, but they also said they want to do it as 3 films with the second film (it might have been third) focusing more on Rhodes for obvious reasons which I wont go into. Only thing is I dont think they made his character strong enough to play a big role (and especially the role hes going to go into). So unless Stark rubs off on him and he develops more personality, I can see him being abit dull but I could be wrong.
 
It was nice to see a potrayal of Tony Stark that didn't involve him being George W. Bush in a powered armor suit and even less morals, unlike the way the comics have portrayed him the past three years.

It took me ages to figure out that the terrorist organization was loosely based on the Mandarin and according to the novelization is actually RUN by the Mandarin behind the scenes.
 
Oh my god, I forgot to stay after the frickin' credits! DAMMIT! I'm probably gonna see it again anyway...

In my opinion The Iron Monger made the movie.
 
I loved it, and I agree it's the best Marvel movie so far. In retrospect, I think it worked better not to have Iron Maiden's "Iron Man" playing until the credits. Would've been to cheesy.

I absolutely loved Robert Downey Jr. and Gwyneth Paltrow, their chemistry was perfect. He was perfect as Stark, and all of the comedy scenes were funny, no doubt about it. For some reason the interaction between Stark and Pepper was absolutely perfect from start to finish.
 
In retrospect, I think it worked better not to have Iron Maiden's "Iron Man" playing until the credits.

I'll assume you meant to say Black Sabbath, but yeah, I agree. That movie made my week, most likely month. My only hope is that the obviously forthcoming
Avengers
movie is better. It should be. If it isn't, it will disappoint me to no end.

Also...
BEST.STAN.LEE.CAMEO.EVER.
 
It was nice to see a potrayal of Tony Stark that didn't involve him being George W. Bush in a powered armor suit and even less morals, unlike the way the comics have portrayed him the past three years.

It took me ages to figure out that the terrorist organization was loosely based on the Mandarin and according to the novelization is actually RUN by the Mandarin behind the scenes.

He was just behind the scenes? That wasn't him that got scarred by Stark? I figured it to be the original Mandarin or Temujin. Especially with it being unclear if he actually died (it seemed to be HINTED AT...but not actually seen).

...I can't believe I forgot to look for the novelization. Did Peter David write it (as he seems to write ALL OF THEM. Which isn't a bad thing)?

Parasite Black said:
In my opinion The Iron Monger made the movie.

I've already said what my main complaint regarding him was, but he did help to tie things together and it definitely wouldn't have been as good without him.

Æsahættr said:
I loved it, and I agree it's the best Marvel movie so far. In retrospect, I think it worked better not to have Iron Maiden's "Iron Man" playing until the credits. Would've been to cheesy.

My biggest fear after the first full trailer was that they'd play that song throughout the entire film. Just...a constant soundtrack. But waiting until he said that final line was great timing.
 
I loved the soundtrack to this movie. I'll probably go buy it when it comes out.
 
I absolutely adored it! The action and comedy were to the extent that I could easily forgive a few nagging details:

1) The ID of the bad guy wasn't really much of a surprise ... pegged it after the introduction.

2) Tony Stark is like Indy ... lives only, apparently, because the writers say so. :D

3) Jarvis, who can run the house AND help with the suit ... yet can't be called upon to help out after Tony's attacked at his house.

And the last line blew me away. I'm dying to see a sequel now. Missed the clip post-credits cause we needed to get home.
 
An awesome kick off to the summer movie season. Marvel outdid themselves this time. The portrayal of the characters and the acting was brilliant as was the storytelling. Of course the special effects were also great.

I think the scene in the beginning where he saw the Stark logo on the missile that injured him was a nice touch. It really made his change after returning home have depth.

I'll likely go see Speed Racer. I know moviegoers are cautious about it but you never know. The Chronicles of Narnia come out the week after. If Iron Man is any indication, this will be a very good year for the movies.
 
I absolutely adored it! The action and comedy were to the extent that I could easily forgive a few nagging details:

1) The ID of the bad guy wasn't really much of a surprise ... pegged it after the introduction.

That...was bad. But, admittedly, how many comic films have a hard-to-find villain? I'm not saying that it makes it okay, but it's fairly par for the course.

2) Tony Stark is like Indy ... lives only, apparently, because the writers say so. :D

Why do you say that? They went into his past, how he came to where he was (albeit briefly), and explained, admittedly between the lines, why he was who he was prior to being captured.

3) Jarvis, who can run the house AND help with the suit ... yet can't be called upon to help out after Tony's attacked at his house.

Well, keep in mind that Tony was undergoing cardiac arrest, and that Jarvis was basically just a voice-operated program. I'm sure in the next film he'll have some sort of defensive programming built in, but after getting back from Afghanistan, Tony had spent all his time working on the MK II armor and didn't even THINK he would be attacked in his own home. Besides, he's rich, who would DARE attack him in his own home?

And the last line blew me away. I'm dying to see a sequel now. Missed the clip post-credits cause we needed to get home.

Perfect reason to get the DVD.

Forgive me if any of that sounded...anything less than friendly (wasn't meant to be unfriendly, but it's all about how it's read). But you dared question a comic book movie. I'm forced to defend it, on principle alone. If not, they take away my nerd card.
 
What was wrong with the last line?

That was so funny with the War Machine tease and the recurring joke about no one being about to remember what SHIELD stands for. I was not expecting Jarvis to be movie-fied as a computer helper program.

Downey fits Stark like a glove, like everyone's already pointed out.

I'm hardly what you would call a fan of Iron Man, but this movie rocked. Gonna buy the DVD. :>
 
What was wrong with the last line?

Like I said, if they "undo it" (by that, I mean they find a way to make it seem like he was lying, not just ignore it) like they have in the comics, then it's fine. Otherwise...they just miss out on all the fun "is he? Isn't he?" stuff (not like I'll boycott the movie if they don't undo it, I just have my preferences). I'm hoping that that line plays into why Rhodes gets the suit (which would be a spoiler if it weren't obvious to everyone who saw it that he'll end up in it. Whether as War Machine or Iron Man is another matter).
 
OMG, this movie was freakin awesome.

The combination of action and humor was amazing. I loved it. And Fury at the end was great. :D

When it comes to comics and shows and such I like Iron Man but I'm not as into it as I am X-Men and Spider-Man. But when it comes to the movies, Iron Man blew everyone out of the water.
 
I'll assume you meant to say Black Sabbath, but yeah, I agree. That movie made my week, most likely month. My only hope is that the obviously forthcoming
Avengers
movie is better. It should be. If it isn't, it will disappoint me to no end.

Also...
BEST.STAN.LEE.CAMEO.EVER.

Whoops my bad. My friends are huge Maiden fans so they'd probably kick my arse if I said that around them. Thank you for correcting me. :lol:
 
When Pepper is hacking Stane's computer, "Lebowski" flashes on the screen. BEST. EASTER EGG. EVER!
Yeah, so I skipped school to see this movie on Friday, and it was totally worth it.
 
I'll likely go see Speed Racer. I know moviegoers are cautious about it but you never know.

A little offtopic,but I heard from the early screenings it's great if you like cartoons or the classic anime and horrible if you go in expecting the Matrix but with racecars. It's very faithful, but a lot of people complained about it because the billing of the Wachowski siblings made people expect a ultra-violent philosophical movie. About Speed Racer. For real.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom