It's disturbing how well the boxes worked out.

Joined
Aug 20, 2007
Messages
3,459
Reaction score
3,623
In the game, PC boxes are 6x5, and therefore can hold 30 Pokémon each. Since there are 18 of them, you are able to hold a total of 540 Pokémon in your boxes.

It was around the time Gold and Silver were out that I started having thoughts about having a copy of every Pokémon in the PC. Of course, I never actually did do it, moreso due to laziness than a lack of obsessiveness. The thought periodically cropped up as I continued to play through the games over and over, and Diamond and Pearl was no exception.

So as I stated, you can hold 540 Pokémon in the boxes. There are 493 Pokémon, so if you want to get a copy of every one of them, you can comfortably fit them all within the boxes. You'll end up with 47 spaces to spare.

But wait! There are certain Pokémon that have alternate forms to them. shinies, gender differences, the ridiculous amount of Spinda variations...I excluded those from the count. But there are still others out there, that aren't any of these, that one might want to collect.

Unown is one that immediately comes to mind - it has 28 forms. Since one of them is already accounted for in the initial Pokémon count, we subtract 27 from 47 to get the amount of space remaining. 20 slots.

But then there's Burmy and Wormadam to consider. They have three forms each. Again, since two of these are accounted for in the initial count, we subtract four from 20, and end up with 16.

Then there's Shellos and Gastrodon. That's another two. We're at 14 now. Deoxys is also included as having multiple forms. Getting by the difficulty of obtaining four of them, we'd end up with 11 slots. So what else is there?

Arceus.

It has 17 forms in total. Again, getting by the difficulty of obtaining 17 of them, one is accounted for, so we subtract 16 from 11 and end up with -5.

Remember, you have room for up to six Pokémon in your party. So really, you can hold up to 546 at a time. Add six to -5 and you have one. One empty slot, and a whole variety of explanations.

One that I found interesting was Arceus' unused ??? type form. If it were obtainable, all the slots would be able to be filled up. It's not though, so you have a spare slot to do whatever you want with. Another possible explanation is that this extra slot is so that you can get eggs from the daycare. Without that slot, you'd have no room. Or, maybe it was for that, and for the general catching of anything you desire.

It can also be noted that if you really want to look at the big picture, you have another three slots - two in the daycare, and one in the GTS. Although they're hardly stable; daycare Pokémon level up in there and may have their movesets ruined (although this can be circumvented with Level 100s or ones that don't matter if they level, such as Ditto), and the GTS Pokémon may be traded or purged after not being traded for so long.

What is that empty slot really for? I don't know. Am I the first to notice this? I don't know. Was this intentional, or just a really big coincidence? I don't know. All I know is that it works, and that looking deep into things may reveal information that you might not want to know.
 
It can also be noted that if you really want to look at the big picture, you have another three slots - two in the daycare, and one in the GTS. Although they're hardly stable; daycare Pokémon level up in there and may have their movesets ruined (although this can be circumvented with Level 100s or ones that don't matter if they level, such as Ditto), and the GTS Pokémon may be traded or purged after not being traded for so long.

What is that empty slot really for? I don't know. Am I the first to notice this? I don't know. Was this intentional, or just a really big coincidence? I don't know. All I know is that it works, and that looking deep into things may reveal information that you might not want to know.
It's for the sake of people who're claustrophobic over things like that, with a little room to breathe, and to have a place to store just /one/ more, if they happen upon a shiny or are trying to bag something with decent IVs, OR to put one away from the party to rescue the floaters in the GTS or Daycare, or yes, for an egg. ...Although anyone crazy enough to try for four Deoxys and 17 Arceus /just/ to own the alt forms really needs a better hobby.

Still, decent snooping.
 
Uhm, just a coincidence - I mean come on, Arcaeus isn't even out and you're already planning on 17 of them...

Not to mention your Deoxys theory... I mean spare clonin I simply can't imagine gettin 4 of them.
 
Plus you've not considered gender differences. If you're going to count Shellos and Gastrodon twice, you've also got to count gender differences. =)
 
Not to mention this "limit" is pretty moot when you have several games :p
 
Not to mention people like to collect shiny forms. If we were to include all that, the number would be too large. Now, I know how precise people like to be, but for me, I only store the fully evolved forms of what I have. I think this significantly reduces the number. It will take a while to count for that, though. I don't think that even that would solve the storage problem. It presents an interesting dilemma for the proponents of another gen, though, as 493 pokemon alone almost fill the storage. If they make more pokes, they will have to expand the PC boxes, or it will just not be possible to collect these things anymore.
 
What happens if you try to catch a Pokemon when you're boxes and party is full?
 
The only reason I started my full dex is because I get annoyed when I go see the Journalist guy in Solaceon town and he asks me for a pokemon I don't have...

All that for 3 measly free Pokeballs/day...
 
It presents an interesting dilemma for the proponents of another gen, though, as 493 pokemon alone almost fill the storage. If they make more pokes, they will have to expand the PC boxes, or it will just not be possible to collect these things anymore.
This "dilemma" is anything but new; every generation has had the Storage System quota set to be greater than the number of overall Pokémon up to that generation, but lower than that number added by 100. Consequently, a uniform system used for the games of more than one generation has never been possible. In case you have not noticed, the Generation I Storage System comprised of 12 boxes of 20 slots, the Generation II system of 14 boxes of the same space, the Generation III system of 15 boxes of 30 slots, and as mentioned, the Generation IV Storage System has 3 additional boxes of the same space.

At any rate, I would like to challenge the idea of counting the different Burmy, Deoxys and Arceus forms towards filling the quota. Unlike Unown, Shellos, Gastrodon and even Wormadam, the above mentioned species do not have a constant form, and thus, a display of all forms is essentially redundant (one representative, able to shift to the rest of the forms, is sufficient). If the count including these forms were indeed 546, rather than 545, I would at least be able to fathom Game Freak's designing the Storage System with such an idea in mind - but that isn't the case.
 
I think a Pokemon Box for the Wii would be a nice idea imo. It'd work pretty well considering how easy PBR has shown to upload your whole box/team.
 
Whoa, really?

I was hoping the Pokemon would get lost in some bizarre void..
 
It isn't really that hard to get 4 Deoxys. I had 3 at one time. 2 were for trading purposes, so I didn't bother to get a 4th one.

But I think it is just a big coincidence
 
Hmm I sort of agree with System Error, the designers didn't choose 540 at random, they certainly took all that into account. However, 17 Arceus.... O.O
 
540 with 493. Well, I know for a fact whenever Generation V comes out, they'll have to have at least another three or four boxes, provided they keep their current size.

Seeing that the box space has increased by 300 while the number of Pokémon has increased by 342, they're gonna have to start adding more space per generation if they're ever to reach that supposed "goal" of 1000 Pokémon.

As for the all-forms living Pokédex just barely fitting... well that has to be a coincidence. After all, if it wasn't, then Gen I would have 151 spaces, but it has 240. Gen II would have had 276, but it has 286. Gen III would have had 413, but it has 426. So Gen IV just cuts it really close with 545/546 filled. It's not some plan by Game Freak (at least it doesn't seem to be), but it is odd.
 
Each pokemon takes memory...

Chances are that the number of boxes available is dictated by memory available on the cartrige more than anything else -- I'll test this theory later on with an emulator...

Each PC stored pokemon takes 80bytes (back in Gen III, though I don't see why it'd be any bigger in Gen IV since there's nothing new in the pokemon themselves) so that makes 43200 bytes or a bit over 40K.

Also important to note is adding a new box would require 2400bytes more.

DS supports these memory formats (over 40K...):
EEPROM 64K
FLASH 256K
FLASH 512K

Two question remain: what's the real size used and how much data is reserved for game stuff.
 
Last edited:
i belive they have enogh boxes for all of the pokemon, a box for unown and mayby a spare if you want it. i am, and have been for a while, doing the all pokemon thing on my emerald. i was also doing it on my diamond but i changed my mind. i have noticed the calculated rise from V3 to V4 but never counted forms and never considered getting 4 deoxys or 17/18 arcius.

dont forget that you ccan also have an egg in daycare when you are counting as well. i dont think they took the forms into acount in making the boxes. i would also like to let you know that all types of spinda wont fit in your boxes as even if they were all filled with spinda, and your party, and the daycare, and the GTS, and even if you had 3 games like this!!! (if you did try to get all the spinda it makes you officialy SAD especailly getting that many games just to catch spinda).

also by the time the next pokemon comes out, it might not even be on NDS!!!
 
Last edited:
Please note: The thread is from 19 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom