• Forum Moderator applications are now open! If you're interested in joining an active team of moderators for one of the biggest Pokémon forums on the internet, click here for info.

Contest Lava Cookie vs Old Gateau vs Casteliacone

F

Fudgenuggets

H...a...p...p...y
Joined
Dec 23, 2009
Messages
1,060
Reaction score
3
Bag_Lava_Cookie_Sprite.png
VS
Bag_Old_Gateau_Sprite.png
VS
Bag_Casteliacone_Sprite.png


Which has the better design?

Which do you prefer?

Which do you think is tastier?

... I'm hungry. *goes to get a snack*
 
design - caselia cone looks cute.
prefer - lava cookie. i want to taste lava.
tastier - SLOWPOKE'S TAIL!
 
Design- Casteliacone is beautiful.
Prefer- Casteliacone, because of its appearance and the line thing.
Tastier- Casteliacone. I like ice cream better.
 
Better design? Lava Cookie. Old Gateau is bland, and Casteliacone doesn't look too different from a regular ice cream cone.

Which do I prefer? Lava Cookie. It's easily available to me in Platinum don't know about other regions, though.

Which is tastier? Lava Cookie. Based on design alone, as long as it ain't spicy. :murg:
 
I've had Old Gateau before. It's been a while, though, but I can ascertain that it was really good.
 
In its introductory generation, the Lava Cookie has been more available than the other two, and I like cookies
 
I end up using Lava Cookies. They tend to be more readily available in the games, so I don't feel as bad about using them and potentially removing their listing from the collection of items in my bag.
 
Caseliacone. Its a ice cream And it's based off a pokemon how could you go wrong. So it automaticlly wins in all the categories lol.

Now excuse me, i need to go eat :-p
 
Which has the better design?
Casteliacone.
Which do you prefer?
Old Gateau, since it is the most effective.
Which do you think is tastier?
Casteliacone.

Casteliacone it is, then.
 
Who doesn't love the taste of molten rock?

The Old Gateau is ugly...

The Casteliacone is nice I guess, I just don't like having to wait for Tuesday or whenever it is and then waiting in line for it.
 
MMMM, scorching lava! I wait a week for ice cream! I'm in the mood for some Jello. :) Old Gateau reminds me of it.
 
Last edited:
Which has the better design?

Casteliacone. It's pretty.

Which do you prefer?

Lava Cookie. It's awesome due to being from Hoenn and being under that truck.

Which do you think is tastier?

Casteliacone probably.
 
Lava Cookie, because you can get them easily. I want a cookie now...
 
Castelia Cone!

But what if Lava Cookie and Castelia Cone are together? In one snack package? Yummier I guess...
 
Lava Cookie because I hope it has chocolate chips. Old Gateau looks gross and I don`t even know how to get a Casteliacone... the lines are always full and they don`t sell them in winter. I`ll work on it. ;-)
 
Which has the better design?

Lava Cookie, definitely.

Which do you prefer?

The cookie!

Which do you think is tastier?

Hard to say. I guess the cookie would taste best. I like burnt cookies.
 
i prefer ice cream over old gelatin and a spicy/burnt cookie any day <3

Teravolt71 said:
Lava Cookie because I hope it has chocolate chips. Old Gateau looks gross and I don`t even know how to get a Casteliacone... the lines are always full and they don`t sell them in winter. I`ll work on it. ;-)
Click to expand...

go on tuesdays in any other season.
 
Lava Cookie, for my general love of cookies and the fact they are easily available in Platinum. Too bad that changed by B/W... but it's still my preferred one.
 
Please note: The thread is from 5 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom