• Forum Moderator applications are now open! If you're interested in joining an active team of moderators for one of the biggest Pokémon forums on the internet, click here for info.

New Year Star Showdown

P

PokemonFan999

New Member
Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
21
Reaction score
0
Due to the popularity of my Christmas Competition, I've decided to do another 1, its running till the end of January and to eneter you need to give me your answer to this question:
"Who would win in a 3-way fight, Dialga, Palkia or Giratina?"
Post your answer in up to 5 sentences follwed by your FC, in game name(s) and preferable trading times. The winner can then select 3 events from the list belows, then I'll also choose 1 altogether winner who will win 1 of all those events
Here is the events list of what you can win:
Events

  1. arceus
    pcp
    nz jirachi

    UK shaymin

    world 09 weavile
    world 08 lucario
    world 07 pikachu
    gamestop

    Mystery Mew (UT)

    tru manaphy
    tru gigas
    tru dragonite
    TRU shaymin
    TRU Arceus

    e4all Manaphy

    Michina Arceus

    distant land
    moltres
    zapdos
    articuno
    lugia
    raikou
    suicine
    entei
    umbreon

    mcdonalds pikachu

    HG/SS Event Dialga/Giratina

    all pktopia

    vgc09 milotic
    hadou regis
    hadou mew

    Kyoto CMEX pikachu

    baba Flygon

    palacity mew
    palacity lucario

    almia darkrai
    alamos darkrai
    movie darkrai

    10th aniv
    absol
    blaziken
    celebi
    pikachu
    latias
    latios

    saikou
    milotic
    salamence

    NOKS
    Rayquaza
    Magmortar
    Arcainnie
    Pikachu
    Shaymin
    Electivire
    Tangragrowth

    Golgo Octillery

    Akiyama Slaking

    wishmaker jirachi

    ruby and saphire Zigzagoon

    Space C deoxys

    UK Regigigas

    Bday
    Pikachu
    Charmander
    chimchar

    pkmn Center
    Meowth
    eevee

    Red Metagross

    Concert Chatot

    And Last But not Least...

    Mitsurin and Aghetto Celebi!!

    So what are you waiting for?
    Start posting reasons now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Ok in that fight, it would for sure be Dialga. Reason, Roar of Time. If you look at it, Giratina is dragon type and so is Palkia. Which of course means, that if Dialga uses Roar of Time, it is super effective and it is 1 of the most powerful dragon type moves. It may not 1 hit ko but it would do some heavy damage!!!

FC: 3051 8163 7433
Name: Mike

I can usaually trade almost all the times, more likely available in the morning.... As long as it is before Jan. 4, i can usually trade almost all the time!
 
I would have to give it to Dialga. It may not have the best signature move, but it's main power is having useful resistances. It is a dragon type that actually does not have a weakness to dragons. Palkia and Giratina do have a resistance to Dragon types, causing them to be OHKO'd or severely damaged by Draco Meteor. It is also immune to toxic, so neither of the two can use that in an attempt to defeat Dialga.

Friend Code: 1591 2459 2462
In-Game Name: Angad
I am usually on at around 11 AM (EST) to about 10 PM (EST.)
 
I would have to hand it to Diagla because, most importantly, it has type effective moves. A dragon move (let's say roar of time) is effective against another dragon, which can be deadly. But most of all, it depends how you raised the legends. A trained Giratina can easily wall against an un-trained diagla. But, I'm still going with Diagla.

Name:Chebon
FC:0431-7274-3792

I can trade ANY time, before Jan.4, since that's when school starts -.-
Merry Christmas.

Thanks.
 
Dialga would win! He`s the most handsome of the three Dragos [he :,D] and with Roar of Time, I`m sure he would beat those too other! As Giratina is hiding in the Distortion World, I`m sure he isn`t that harmful. As for Dialga, He has Spacial Rand, but it isn`t as powerful as Roar of Time. Of course it depends how you train them, and I`m sure that every Drago is good with they own way.
I also choose Dialga, `cos he`s my favourite of the Dragon Trio, and also one of my favourite Legendary from 4th Generation. Besides, Diamond`s are girls best friends! ;3

Name: Eve
FC: 2364 1642 1609
I can trade almost every time, as I have my holiday right now ^__^ Our time zone is UTC +2.
 
I would have to hand it to Giratina. If it was powerful and troublesome enough that Arceus would banish it, I think that puts it in a different class from palkia and dialga. Plus, Giratina has powerful endurance (HP) and above average defenses, and he can learn how to use moves that are super effective against palkia (dragon claw) and dialga (earth power, aura sphere). Finally, his signature move (shadow force) is impossible to dodge and protects him from one turn of attacks

My Name: Kyle
FC: 2234 5977 6237
Can trade anytime I'm on, which is about 2pm-8pm GMT-5
 
Last edited:
I personally think that it would be hard to actually determine which one out of Giratina, Palkia and Dialga could win, they all could win for different reasons.
Like Dialga would have the advantage with the Dragonmove Roar of Time as both Giratina and Palkia are Dragon types and Dragon moves are quite effective on Dragon type pokemon.
Giratina could win because it's quite a troublesome pokemon and is very persistent plus if Arceus had to banish it, that just proves that Giratina is very powerful and also Shadow Claw is very powerful and could weaken either Dialga or Palkia easily with a good hit.
Palkia could win if it used Dragon Claw, Earth Power or Aura Sphere on either one of them to win.

Name: Brooke
FC: 0560 6856 8884
My timezone is GMT +11, i can usually train whenever as I'm generally online most days :)
Have a good Christmas :D
 
Last edited:
palkia would win because all it would have to do is use earth power/aura sphere on dialga and spacial rend on giratina.
name:Akiza
fc:2192-3537-5801
time availible:saturdays from 6:30 pm - 8 pm btw i am in cdt.
 
Last edited:
None of them would win. Ash would arrive before things got interesting, say some stuff about love, and kindness, and all that crap, and then Pikachu would say "Pika Pika", and then someone would die, and then they'd come back to life because of friendship, and if that happened in real life we'd just have a load of zombies running around so that's damn stupid, and then Pikachu would say "Pika Pika" again, and the three dragons we be so sad they'd all go back to wherever they came from, completely ruining the most interesting fight that ever happened in the history of the world. Then Pikachu would say "Pika Pika" again.

Friend code: 2063/9796/8790
 
Hmm, I'd hate to go with the crowd, but I'm going to give it to Dialga. Dialga could slow the flow of time and beat up on slow-motion Palkia and Giratina. Dialga could also withstand more in a fair fight since he's made of steel, which compensates for his natural weakness to dragons. Then again, Arceus could come rushing out of Toys R Us and start throwing all of their special moves around.

Diamond Code: 1118 6505 8548
Trainer name: Zell
 
Last edited:
I think Palkia would win because he can do moves that are super effective against Dialga and Giratina. Palkia's speed is naturally faster than Dialga and Giratina so he'll make the first move and do a good amount of heavy damage. Palkia can also distort space, so he can just attack Dialga and Giratina while they just float helplessly in the air while he does some more awesome damage. I would love to see Palkia win :3
I also like Palkia 'cause he's sort of based of of a dinosaur called Plateosaurus, and I love to draw and read about dinosaurs :D

FC: 284 7999 3242
Trainer Name: ARI (all in caps)

If it's the weekend (in my country Wednesday (after school it's the beginning of the weekend), Thursday, and Friday are the weekends) I can trade any time, if it's the week days then I can trade only after homework at 20:00-22:00 my timezone (GMT time e.g. 16:00 = 4:00 PM my timezone).
 
Giratina would win. He would use Shadow Force, and while he disappears Palkia would defeat Dialga with Aura Sphere, and Dialga would defeat Palkia with Roar of Time. When Giratina appears the figth will be over, and Giratina is victorious :D

Name: Espen
FC: 1977 8193 9893
I usually can trade every day after 5 pm. (My timezone is utc +1)
 
Dialga would win, as Dialga has both a resistance to Giratina and Palkia's alternative STAB (Ghost and Water respectively). Giratina may have high defenses, but it has mediocre offenses, so even if Giratina used Earth Power/Aura Sphere, it wouldn't do much to Dialga. Palkia is the most fragile one out of the three, I believe, so a Dragon Pulse/Draco Meteor/Roar of Time would easily defeat Palkia. If Palkia gets lucky with a critical hit on Aura Sphere, it might win, but that's factoring in a lot of luck.

FC: 3781-5844-6636
 
Palkia would win because he have hind legs, this of course confuses Giratina which has either no one or 8 and Dialga get jalousie because it's stuck on all 4. Therefor Palkia wins for sure.

Before 4.January I can trade anytime. But I would prefer around 00.00 GMT+1

In-game name: Kake
My FC: 5027 5144 1757
 
Please note: The thread is from 16 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom