unrepentantAuthor
A cat who writes stories
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2012
- Messages
- 1,631
- Reaction score
- 1,132
I recently bought a new laptop, and in the process of moving across all my files (and taking the opportunity to discard some trash) I rediscovered my cache of old fanfiction and other writing. It got me thinking about how much I've improved in the twelve or so years I've been interested in writing.
This thread is the result of that train of thought. It's a bit messy, my apologies. I hope it's worth a read! I'm going to provide a few examples of my writing over time, talk a little bit about what's helped me improve as a writer in the last decade, and offer some ideas about how to develop your own skills.
Everyone is welcome to post their own "before and after" excerpts and discuss personal development in the craft! Alright, here we go.
Below is the first piece of fanfic writing I ever published online. I used to feel physical pain looking back at it, but it's been long enough now that I can chill out about it and share it with you lovely folks. And yes, as you might expect, it was about pokémorphs.
That's... the entire opening chapter, right there. Angsty, needlessly grimdark, awkward description and dialogue, tells rather than shows while telling almost nothing. At least the technical aspects aren't too bad, considering — which actually makes me wonder if I edited this at all. Probably not, though.
The story I just excerpted ran almost 120k words long, and told the story of a bunch of angsty pokémorphs abused by Team Rocket who discovered they were the incarnations of various elements and used their powers to fight various villains. It culminated in some convoluted and confusing nonsense, and I'm pretty sure I made up almost every plot point as I went. It had a ton of dire cliches, including evil shadow-selves, overwrought prophecies, and even an unnecessarily powerful self insert that I cringe to recall.
Here's an excerpt from a previous edition of Different Eyes, published here in 2012:
I think the writing in this excerpt is more interesting, more fluid, and more natural. It doesn't suffer from the same sort of horrible blatant flaws as my work from six years earlier did. However, I do have problems with this story. There's space given to Salem to come to terms with her new body, but apparently in 2012 I hadn't decided whether Salem wanted to be a morph or not. I actually gave her amnesia for some stupid reason, probably just because I hadn't fully decided on her background until I got to chapter five.
The other thing is that she acts more or less like a human. Her perspective on things is only somewhat coloured by her background as a pokémon. Sure, this quote has her fixate on her hands and comment on using a shower, but if I wrote this part again now, I'd have her try and fail to clean herself, try to get help grooming from someone else when she struggled, and have to be directed to the shower and taught how to use it. What's more, she'd be horrified, not blase about showering. She's a cat! As for her hands — well, allow me to quote myself yet again with some very recent writing.
In my latest writing, I've finally figured out how to properly integrate the character's thoughts and feelings into close-third person narration. Salem's reaction to her hands isn't expressed by naming emotions or by explaining her delight, but by comparing the experience to others, having her care more about the utility of her new hands than about pain, and by emphasising how she now is capable of more than she ever was before.
I could go digging for all sorts of comparisons to make, but this thread isn't about me, not really! I promise! Besides, all my old files seem desperately corrupted, (un?)fortunately. I have received a fair bit of praise in recent months, and I wanted to humble myself and show that it's taken a very long time to build up my understanding of the craft, and that talent is not nearly so important as experience.
My experience includes throwing myself into fanfic and abandoning it, and then again, and then somehow throwing myself back into it one more time these past months. It includes a three year university course in creative writing. It includes joining real life writers groups and workshopping my own work and the writing of other people with genuine physical red pens. It includes a whole lot of writing.
They say that if you do anything ten thousand times, you become a master of it. Well, I've written about 300k words, which is surely over ten thousand sentences. I'm still not a master of writing, but I can tell you that if I'd waited twelve years and never written a thing, never received critical feedback, never reexamined my own work and learned from it, then I would not be nearly so able a writer as I am today.
The fact is — and this is the reason I'm posting this friend, my friends — it takes a lot of work to get really good at writing. Maybe that's bad news, I don't tend to see it that way myself. Here's some good news: you're capable of that. Simply put: if you write, you improve. So go write. Improve. It's practically inevitable! Just remember to respect and learn from critical feedback and from other authors. Read widely, edit thoroughly, and keep pushing your comfort zone if you can.
Originally, I had thought to include some thoughts about writing resources, but here we are in The Written Word, a fantastic resource! We have some excellent Academy articles and a whole community of responsive writers to answer threads. Nevertheless, if you're interested in really making deliberate efforts to rapidly improve your writing skill, I have some suggestions:
Wow, hey, as usual I wrote more than I meant to! I hope some of this is useful to some of you.
I invite everyone to share their embarrassing first drafts from the dawn of time and compare them to their proudest recent work. I invite everyone to share encouraging thoughts about improving over time as writers. Lastly, I invite everyone to talk about their own progress and perseverance — how you've kept writing and not given up, and won't give up, and will only get better.
Cheers, all. Many of my fellow writers here have also played a part in my own development. I hope I can play a part in some of yours.
Edit: couple posts down, I've offered up a much more cringey excerpt. It's real bad.
This thread is the result of that train of thought. It's a bit messy, my apologies. I hope it's worth a read! I'm going to provide a few examples of my writing over time, talk a little bit about what's helped me improve as a writer in the last decade, and offer some ideas about how to develop your own skills.
Everyone is welcome to post their own "before and after" excerpts and discuss personal development in the craft! Alright, here we go.
Below is the first piece of fanfic writing I ever published online. I used to feel physical pain looking back at it, but it's been long enough now that I can chill out about it and share it with you lovely folks. And yes, as you might expect, it was about pokémorphs.
“My name is Ember.”
The Sandslash morph chuckled.
“And you are what?” he asked.
“A Charmeleon morph,” the golden lizard answered. He lay on the narrow, crude bed, his flaming tail hanging over the side.
“But you’re not red! Charmeleons are red. What sort of Pokemon were you?”
“The humans call me a ‘shiny’. Other Pokemon called me a freak.”
“You are that.”
The Sandslash morph was a pale brown, but darker, spiky, armour plates covered his back and head. Unusually for a Pokemorph, he had dark black hair. He shifted uncomfortably due to his spikes.
The cell was small and dark, lit only by Ember’s tail.
Ember himself was golden with angular features and a reptilian head, which was much like his original, like most regular Pokemorphs. Both were humanoid, to the point where they seemed part human, which they were.
They looked like Pokemon gifted, or cursed, with human features. They both had clawed hands and sharp teeth. They wore black Team Rocket uniforms, complete with the red ‘R’ on the tops.
“And now, I’m this,” the Charmeleon continued. “A freak among freaks...”
This is how it all ends…
He smiled faintly. “All I had... Reduced to cinders...”
The Sandslash morph chuckled.
“And you are what?” he asked.
“A Charmeleon morph,” the golden lizard answered. He lay on the narrow, crude bed, his flaming tail hanging over the side.
“But you’re not red! Charmeleons are red. What sort of Pokemon were you?”
“The humans call me a ‘shiny’. Other Pokemon called me a freak.”
“You are that.”
The Sandslash morph was a pale brown, but darker, spiky, armour plates covered his back and head. Unusually for a Pokemorph, he had dark black hair. He shifted uncomfortably due to his spikes.
The cell was small and dark, lit only by Ember’s tail.
Ember himself was golden with angular features and a reptilian head, which was much like his original, like most regular Pokemorphs. Both were humanoid, to the point where they seemed part human, which they were.
They looked like Pokemon gifted, or cursed, with human features. They both had clawed hands and sharp teeth. They wore black Team Rocket uniforms, complete with the red ‘R’ on the tops.
“And now, I’m this,” the Charmeleon continued. “A freak among freaks...”
This is how it all ends…
He smiled faintly. “All I had... Reduced to cinders...”
That's... the entire opening chapter, right there. Angsty, needlessly grimdark, awkward description and dialogue, tells rather than shows while telling almost nothing. At least the technical aspects aren't too bad, considering — which actually makes me wonder if I edited this at all. Probably not, though.
The story I just excerpted ran almost 120k words long, and told the story of a bunch of angsty pokémorphs abused by Team Rocket who discovered they were the incarnations of various elements and used their powers to fight various villains. It culminated in some convoluted and confusing nonsense, and I'm pretty sure I made up almost every plot point as I went. It had a ton of dire cliches, including evil shadow-selves, overwrought prophecies, and even an unnecessarily powerful self insert that I cringe to recall.
Here's an excerpt from a previous edition of Different Eyes, published here in 2012:
Pensive and apprehensive - even more so than usual - Salem decided to find her way to her team's quarters. Thankfully, she was now adept enough at walking as a biped that she barely needed to concentrate, and could think about other things while doing so. The journey to the billet let her come to terms a little with her situation. She realised this was the first time she'd been both alone and awake as a morph, and therefore the first time she'd had a chance to pause, to think, to be free of any pressing concern.
She surprised herself by thinking mainly of Dusk. It seemed more rational to her to consider her strange and bewildering circumstances, and to piece together information about her new life, but when she invited any thought to enter her head, she found her chiefest concern was for her sneasel friend. It wasn't as if she didn't feel inquisitive about her material uncertainties, but she'd been materially uncertain since waking up in a new body with a new mind. Being uncertain about a friend was the unfamiliar feeling.
She forcibly put the thought out of her mind, choosing to leave social worries until later. Besides; who was she, a former housecat, to fret about the wellbeing of someone so comfortable in her own skin as Dusk? The pragmatic thing to do - she decided - was to look over the copy of her dossier Mark had given her, or perhaps peruse her supply of books. She'd also been itching to pour her mind into her notebook since she'd left the library.
She found the door to her team's female quarters easily enough, sighing with the reassurance that her sense of direction was apparently intact. There was no answer when she knocked, so she entered into an empty room. She noted with relief that her belongings, such as they were, lay at the foot of the second bed.
The quarters, though not especially spacious, contained three folding wall-beds, each with a locker, in the main room. There were a surprising number of amenities, including a large shower in the en-suite bathroom and even a medical kit. She expected she'd have to use the shower now that she was no longer flexible enough to reach every part of her body with her tongue. Hopefully it was adapted for use by morphs.
She seated herself on the edge of the bed - just a mattress, really - and reflexively kneaded the pleasantly soft covers with her paws... hands. She still couldn't decide if her paws were now hands. She flexed her fingers, interlocked them, fanned them, steepled them, curled them into fists. It felt right. It felt wonderful. It felt alien.
She surprised herself by thinking mainly of Dusk. It seemed more rational to her to consider her strange and bewildering circumstances, and to piece together information about her new life, but when she invited any thought to enter her head, she found her chiefest concern was for her sneasel friend. It wasn't as if she didn't feel inquisitive about her material uncertainties, but she'd been materially uncertain since waking up in a new body with a new mind. Being uncertain about a friend was the unfamiliar feeling.
She forcibly put the thought out of her mind, choosing to leave social worries until later. Besides; who was she, a former housecat, to fret about the wellbeing of someone so comfortable in her own skin as Dusk? The pragmatic thing to do - she decided - was to look over the copy of her dossier Mark had given her, or perhaps peruse her supply of books. She'd also been itching to pour her mind into her notebook since she'd left the library.
She found the door to her team's female quarters easily enough, sighing with the reassurance that her sense of direction was apparently intact. There was no answer when she knocked, so she entered into an empty room. She noted with relief that her belongings, such as they were, lay at the foot of the second bed.
The quarters, though not especially spacious, contained three folding wall-beds, each with a locker, in the main room. There were a surprising number of amenities, including a large shower in the en-suite bathroom and even a medical kit. She expected she'd have to use the shower now that she was no longer flexible enough to reach every part of her body with her tongue. Hopefully it was adapted for use by morphs.
She seated herself on the edge of the bed - just a mattress, really - and reflexively kneaded the pleasantly soft covers with her paws... hands. She still couldn't decide if her paws were now hands. She flexed her fingers, interlocked them, fanned them, steepled them, curled them into fists. It felt right. It felt wonderful. It felt alien.
I think the writing in this excerpt is more interesting, more fluid, and more natural. It doesn't suffer from the same sort of horrible blatant flaws as my work from six years earlier did. However, I do have problems with this story. There's space given to Salem to come to terms with her new body, but apparently in 2012 I hadn't decided whether Salem wanted to be a morph or not. I actually gave her amnesia for some stupid reason, probably just because I hadn't fully decided on her background until I got to chapter five.
The other thing is that she acts more or less like a human. Her perspective on things is only somewhat coloured by her background as a pokémon. Sure, this quote has her fixate on her hands and comment on using a shower, but if I wrote this part again now, I'd have her try and fail to clean herself, try to get help grooming from someone else when she struggled, and have to be directed to the shower and taught how to use it. What's more, she'd be horrified, not blase about showering. She's a cat! As for her hands — well, allow me to quote myself yet again with some very recent writing.
Five distinct digits, long and dexterous and complete. A hand. A more or less human hand — albeit still covered in dark fur, still with firm pads, and still tipped with curved retractable claws. A hand all the same. One that could do everything a human hand could. A hand that could do anything at all.
She curled her fingers into a fist, and squeezed. Her claws extended, and dug into her palm, but it felt more wonderful than painful. Tiny swirls of dark blood emptied from the punctures she’d left. She tried to flatten out her hand, then to waggle her fingers individually. The experimental flexing ached awfully, but the satisfaction overwhelmed the discomfort. Nothing had ever been so satisfying. Not a meal, not a warm bed, not a victory. This was the only moment that mattered.
These were her hands. Her hands. Hers.
She curled her fingers into a fist, and squeezed. Her claws extended, and dug into her palm, but it felt more wonderful than painful. Tiny swirls of dark blood emptied from the punctures she’d left. She tried to flatten out her hand, then to waggle her fingers individually. The experimental flexing ached awfully, but the satisfaction overwhelmed the discomfort. Nothing had ever been so satisfying. Not a meal, not a warm bed, not a victory. This was the only moment that mattered.
These were her hands. Her hands. Hers.
In my latest writing, I've finally figured out how to properly integrate the character's thoughts and feelings into close-third person narration. Salem's reaction to her hands isn't expressed by naming emotions or by explaining her delight, but by comparing the experience to others, having her care more about the utility of her new hands than about pain, and by emphasising how she now is capable of more than she ever was before.
I could go digging for all sorts of comparisons to make, but this thread isn't about me, not really! I promise! Besides, all my old files seem desperately corrupted, (un?)fortunately. I have received a fair bit of praise in recent months, and I wanted to humble myself and show that it's taken a very long time to build up my understanding of the craft, and that talent is not nearly so important as experience.
My experience includes throwing myself into fanfic and abandoning it, and then again, and then somehow throwing myself back into it one more time these past months. It includes a three year university course in creative writing. It includes joining real life writers groups and workshopping my own work and the writing of other people with genuine physical red pens. It includes a whole lot of writing.
They say that if you do anything ten thousand times, you become a master of it. Well, I've written about 300k words, which is surely over ten thousand sentences. I'm still not a master of writing, but I can tell you that if I'd waited twelve years and never written a thing, never received critical feedback, never reexamined my own work and learned from it, then I would not be nearly so able a writer as I am today.
The fact is — and this is the reason I'm posting this friend, my friends — it takes a lot of work to get really good at writing. Maybe that's bad news, I don't tend to see it that way myself. Here's some good news: you're capable of that. Simply put: if you write, you improve. So go write. Improve. It's practically inevitable! Just remember to respect and learn from critical feedback and from other authors. Read widely, edit thoroughly, and keep pushing your comfort zone if you can.
Originally, I had thought to include some thoughts about writing resources, but here we are in The Written Word, a fantastic resource! We have some excellent Academy articles and a whole community of responsive writers to answer threads. Nevertheless, if you're interested in really making deliberate efforts to rapidly improve your writing skill, I have some suggestions:
Make writing a habit. I struggle to write every single day, but I do write fairly frequently of late. Stay loose, don't let yourself get rusty. I've had a lot of success giving myself minutes per day to spend writing rather than wordcount goals.
Don't be afraid to discard your writing or of writing substandard prose. Not everything you write is destined for success, and it doesn't have to be. Free yourself from expectations! It's more important to write many words than to write barely anything for fear of falling short of your standards.
Get a beta. It can be pretty hard to find a good beta. I'm pretty lucky to have a decent beta who is perfectly comfortable ripping into my work without mercy. He's helped me move past a lot of my writing weaknesses such as dry prose, exposition dumps, and having all my characters 'smirk' constantly. Thanks, @bluering8.
Read widely! Other fanfiction, published fiction, weird and different stuff that doesn't fit either! I read a lot of SCP Foundation entries, myself. I strongly believe that you cannot hope to excel as a writer without being a regular reader.
Show humility. Even a published author is subject to criticism and people's tastes, not to mention character flaws of their own. We, for the most part, are not published authors but amateur hobbyists and the occasional prospective professional. It's important to be modest about one's abilities in such a context, and to realise that none of us are beyond reproach.
Help others. I've been taught that the best way to really learn something is to try teaching it to someone else. In the same vein, if you really want to improve as a writer, share your knowledge and in the process, strengthen it!
Reply to your reviewers! Reviewers and their feedback are precious, I'm sure we all agree, but if you want them to keep coming, make that extra bit of effort to show you're listening. Otherwise they may as well be shouting into a void.
Understand yourself. Your writing isn't fully separate from you. Being an author is also important. Understand your needs, your strengths, your weaknesses. What you can offer. What you must pursue. What is outside your reach. Figure out how to get yourself writing, because it's different for you than for everyone else. Study not just the craft, but your craft.
Challenge yourself. Write different genres. Write the hard stuff. Write what you normally avoid. Try your hand at NaNoWriMo. Join a writers group, if you can find one. Go the extra mile. Do it. You can.
Don't be afraid to discard your writing or of writing substandard prose. Not everything you write is destined for success, and it doesn't have to be. Free yourself from expectations! It's more important to write many words than to write barely anything for fear of falling short of your standards.
Get a beta. It can be pretty hard to find a good beta. I'm pretty lucky to have a decent beta who is perfectly comfortable ripping into my work without mercy. He's helped me move past a lot of my writing weaknesses such as dry prose, exposition dumps, and having all my characters 'smirk' constantly. Thanks, @bluering8.
Read widely! Other fanfiction, published fiction, weird and different stuff that doesn't fit either! I read a lot of SCP Foundation entries, myself. I strongly believe that you cannot hope to excel as a writer without being a regular reader.
Show humility. Even a published author is subject to criticism and people's tastes, not to mention character flaws of their own. We, for the most part, are not published authors but amateur hobbyists and the occasional prospective professional. It's important to be modest about one's abilities in such a context, and to realise that none of us are beyond reproach.
Help others. I've been taught that the best way to really learn something is to try teaching it to someone else. In the same vein, if you really want to improve as a writer, share your knowledge and in the process, strengthen it!
Reply to your reviewers! Reviewers and their feedback are precious, I'm sure we all agree, but if you want them to keep coming, make that extra bit of effort to show you're listening. Otherwise they may as well be shouting into a void.
Understand yourself. Your writing isn't fully separate from you. Being an author is also important. Understand your needs, your strengths, your weaknesses. What you can offer. What you must pursue. What is outside your reach. Figure out how to get yourself writing, because it's different for you than for everyone else. Study not just the craft, but your craft.
Challenge yourself. Write different genres. Write the hard stuff. Write what you normally avoid. Try your hand at NaNoWriMo. Join a writers group, if you can find one. Go the extra mile. Do it. You can.
Wow, hey, as usual I wrote more than I meant to! I hope some of this is useful to some of you.
I invite everyone to share their embarrassing first drafts from the dawn of time and compare them to their proudest recent work. I invite everyone to share encouraging thoughts about improving over time as writers. Lastly, I invite everyone to talk about their own progress and perseverance — how you've kept writing and not given up, and won't give up, and will only get better.
Cheers, all. Many of my fellow writers here have also played a part in my own development. I hope I can play a part in some of yours.
Edit: couple posts down, I've offered up a much more cringey excerpt. It's real bad.
Last edited: