Rate Ash's water type pokemon

hhhhdmt

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 31, 2009
Messages
646
Reaction score
40
How do you rate the, excluding Lapras which he no longer has?

1. Squirtle
2. Kingler
3. Corphish
4. Buizel
5. Tododile
 
Buizel's fine, and Squirtle's proven itself (plus its one of the originals)

I've never been a big fan though.
 
The rest I assume.

I guess I'd stick with your list. Buizel may be my favorite pokemon out of those on the list, but it hasn't technically proven itself yet.. so I guess we'll have to wait until after the Sinnoh league.
 
They're all good, although Buizel hasn't been doing much lately and I didn't see much of Corphish.

But as for the others, both Squirtle and Totodile have been quite competent battlers. I just found it a little weird that Krabby evolved into Kingler so early. He never used it much, I don't even remember if he used it in the Indigo Conference. But I do remember that it evolved during the Silver Conference, and he was quite awesome at battling. Too bad Ash didn't use Kingler or Squirtle in the final battles.

So I can't really put them in any order. They're all good.
 
Totodile had the least memorable battles, so I'd put it at the end. Totodile never won a single Gym battle.

Squirtle, Buizel and Corphish were all far more impressive, and I'd put Kingler after them.
 
Totodile never won a single Gym battle.

Yeah, but it did rather well against Harrison's Sneasel. And you got to love that dance.

But yeah, I'd possibly rank Squirtle and Kinger higher than Totodile.
 
He never used it much, I don't even remember if he used it in the Indigo Conference. But I do remember that it evolved during the Silver Conference, and he was quite awesome at battling. Too bad Ash didn't use Kingler or Squirtle in the final battles.

No, it was the other way round. In The Indigo Conference, Krabby evolved into Kingler by defeating an Exeggutor. In the Silver Conference, Kingler couldn't participate, because it got knocked out by three Voltorb while training.

On Topic:

1. Squirtle
2. Corphish
3. Buizel
4. Totodile
5. Kingler

I think, Kingler is not as strong as the others, because it wasn't used much. The others are quite close together.
 
No, it was the other way round. In The Indigo Conference, Krabby evolved into Kingler by defeating an Exeggutor. In the Silver Conference, Kingler couldn't participate, because it got knocked out by three Voltorb while training.

You're right, I remember that some Voltorb were rolling down a hill and Kingler saved them but got Thundershocked...

Well, anyway, it still seemed quite strong, considering that it won it's first battle even though it had a type disadvantage, and then evolved immediately after.
 
Kingler was used at the Whirl Cup in Johto, but not in the Johto league.
 
But Ash was going to use it, wasn't he?

I feel that another topic is derailing...

OK, if I had to put them in any particular order, it would probably be

1. Squirtle
2. Totodile
3. Kingler
4. Buizel
5. Corphish
 
My favorites are Squirtle, Corphish, and Buizel. Anyone of them evolved would've been awesome, I'd like to see Ash with an evolved water type. For a while during Hoenn I was hoping Ash with a Crawdaunt. How cool would've that been.
 
1. Corphish
2. Buizel
3. Squirtle
4. Totodile
5. Kingler

Corphish was really funny, Buizel is really cool, Squirtle was kind of cool, Kingler completly unrememorable. Totodile is better than Kingler only for his funny dance haha. I don it out of favourites rather than strongest, I think that's what this thread is about?
 
1. Buizel
2. Squirtle
3. Totodile
4. COrphish
5. Kingler

Kingler was good, just not that useful at times..........as for Buizel, that pokemon PWNS >_< .....Squirle, that is the pokemon that make me like water types....well, most of them
 
Here's my list:

1. Squirtle
2. Buizel
3. Corphish
4. Kingler
5. Totodile

But I do think that Buizel could become Ash's greatest water-type. It all depends on how the rest of Sinnoh turns out and poor Tododile. You may have had a cute dance, but it's battling experience in Johto was just plain sad.
 
Last edited:
Strength:
1. Squirtle
2. Kingler
3. Corphish
4. Buizel
5. Totodile

Personal Preference:
1. Totodile
2. Kingler
3. Squirtle
4. Corphish
5. Buizel
 
My personal choices:

1 - Squirtle
2 - Kingler
3 - Corphish
4 - Totodile
5 - Lapras(I think you can consider as a water type.Or not?)
6 - Buizel
 
It all depends on how the rest of Sinnoh turns out and poor Tododile. You may have had a cute dance, but it's battling experience in Johto was just plain sad.

Yeah, the only thing Totodile had going for it was its voice and the dancing, but otherwise it got such poor treatment it was ridiculous. I didn't find Totodile funny either, unlike some other people, it was incredibly one-dimensional and they didn't get it right with the humor until Corphish.

Thank god Ash brought Squirtle back for the Johto league, Totodile did so poorly it couldn't even beat Macy's fire Pokemon. Sad.
 
Please note: The thread is from 5 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom