This is awkward...

[Lief Katano]

Well, this is awkward...
On Bulbapedia, there is something wrong...
Well, some Key Items that went from Gen II to Gen IV had the same item location, even though the location changed. For example, the Coin Case is now given by Mr. Game (no...not Mr. Game in Watch), but Bulbapedia states it as in Goldenrod Underground, as in GSC. Machine Part=in Cerulean Gym pool, yet it's near the tubes (may be in water, but Dowsing MCHN picks up nothing, zero, zip, nada, g00se eggs). So, I made this thread to say something (well, adimins, I don't see you doing anything).

MOVE THIS IF NEEDED!!!!

 

[Serebii]

Actually, for the Coin Case, Bulbapedia is running off of the Japanese game. In the Japanese game, you got the Coin Case in the underground.

 

[System Error]

Actually, for the Coin Case, Bulbapedia is running off of the Japanese game. In the Japanese game, you got the Coin Case in the underground.

This.

Also, if you want more Gen II/Gen IV awkwardness, the HGSS entries are pretty much just a copy/paste job from the Gold and Silver versions. However, in reality, a number of them are worded differently, such as Hitmontop in HeartGold.

 

[Naya Rivera]

However, in reality, a number of them are worded differently, such as Hitmontop in HeartGold.

Yeah, right now we're working on Hoenn/Sinnoh first and to later fix the Kanto/Johto ones.

 

[MAGNEDETH]

both locations will be noted per generation.
also, this isnt really a major issue, use the stickied thread next time.

 

[Lief Katano]

Actually, for the Coin Case, Bulbapedia is running off of the Japanese game. In the Japanese game, you got the Coin Case in the underground.

Still.
This is the English version of Bulbapedia I'm talking about. They could put:

Location:
US: Given by Mr. Game at Goldenrod Game Corner
JA: Found in the Goldenrod Underground

 

[MAGNEDETH]

im not saying it isnt something we should take care of, im saying this isnt a MAJOR ISSUE that warrants its own thread about it.

 

[Lief Katano]

Weell, someone might look at Bulbapedia for ansewrs then spend 50 hours looking in the GUD.

 

[MAGNEDETH]

still doesnt make it a major error.
of course, being that its a wiki, you could have edited it yourself.

 

[evkl]

Seriously. Minor issue. Closed.