• Forum Moderator applications are now open! If you're interested in joining an active team of moderators for one of the biggest Pokémon forums on the internet, click here for info.

What Type of Rival you prefer for Ash ????

H

Hurricane Kishore

追放されたバカ
Joined
Sep 9, 2011
Messages
1,320
Reaction score
0
As you know , A lot of people is unsatisfied with Trip! (Including me)
So Tell us , The Type of Rival you people would prefer ???
Also how many Rival you would prefer for Ash ???
My Ideal Rival
-1) A ''Cheren'' Like Rival! His Friendship with Ash is similar to Ichigo & Uryu(Bleach)!
Click to expand...

-2) A Cute rich Girl with Similar Personality & Background as Lady Plantina Blatiz(Pokemon Adventure)!
Click to expand...

-3) A Tomboyish Tsundere Rival ! She's hot temper & Really violent & Offensive but Kind & Caring ! She's from a fighting Temple and It want to rise that Temple's reputation by becoming a E4 Champion.
She has habit of hitting & Using Submission Move on People who piss her off (Mainly Ash Who does it Unknowingly). later her first Pokemon reveal to be a Blaziken.
At first She Think Ash as a Werid Boy! But Later she develop a Crush on Ash which is a Common Knowledge to Everyone except Ash!
Click to expand...

-4) A Handsome Delinquent from a Bicycle Gang ! He & He's gang used to bully some Kids from a sudden area!
However After Ash defect him , He disband his Bicycle gang and start a Pokemon Journey to get revenge on Ash!
He hated Ash at first and he was a very rude trainer. But Slowly He Start to change into a good person with his various encounter with Ash.
He also manage to get rid of his hate for Ash as well however He never admit that he now like Ash or He friend with him!
Ash & He has a Fierce Battle in League Where He admit to himself that deep inside he always admired Ash.
After the Battle , He sightly punch Ash telling that He wouldn't forgive Ash if he lose's the next Battle because the Only person who will suppress Ash is Him!
Click to expand...

-5) A Main Superior rival who is 2 or 3 year older then Ash. He's So powerful that he can intimidate people just by his reputation. He achieve Everything that Ash achieve & much more.
It's said that He defected Pyramid King Brandon & his Legendary Golam's without losing a single pokemon (or with just One Pokemon).
He make his first actual physical appearance in the Middle of the Series ! However Ash will learn about him & His incredible Skill from various trainer !(including Gym leader)
He's a complete Battle-freak and all he wants is A Battle that can make his Blood boil! Unlike other main superior Rival , He's Interested in Ash & Believe that Ash is the only one who can be he's equal!
That why He's Want Ash skill to grow further because he think that Ash might be the one who can give him the Blood boiling battle he ever wanted!
He very good-looking & Incredibly popular among girls !
Click to expand...
So , WHAT DO YOU PEOPLE THINK ???
If I was in-charge then Those would be Ash's Rival!
So , Tell me you Idea!!!
 
Last edited:
As long as this new rival isn't an annoying kid like Trip, I don't care.
 
I want at least one rival like Paul because he was amazing. However I would also like some rivals that are friendly.
 
To me, the primary job of a rival is to be a significant threat. They don't have to be stronger than you, but at least on your same skill level while still being able to defeat you from time to time. Paul was the best at being this, but I do understand the importance of changing the premise for a different rival. What I stated is merely the base idea. Everything else can be different.
 
Well, my favorite rivals are Gary and Paul, because they're just ruthless and they were really deemed as a huge threat to Ash. However, I think I want Ash's rival this time around to be particularly ruthless and powerful, yet respectful to Ash and his Pokemon.
 
I guess I like rivals more like Paul, than again even if done right I'd like it. Best Wishes writers just haven't been trying that hard this time with rivalrys.
 
If they can make something with a trainer who traveled like Paul in diffrent region's and won atleast 1 league I am happy I guess.
 
I really don't care anymore. What they did with Paul was pure gold. Whoever did his story plot needs to come back to the show. All they had to do was tone down the Pokemon abuse and you have a worthy rival.

What they need now is a girl rival(other than Bianca) who would be sort of cold and quiet. Maybe her style of dress could be Lolita meaning she would be mysterious. Does she have to be cruel to Pokemon? No. Insulting the boy's intelligence like Trip is doing is fine by me since he doesn't think at times.
 
I don't like Trip at all! He's annoying. Someone who's not too hyper (like Bianca, though I like her somewhat), because it can be quite annoying after a while. Someone who can really be challenged, but not be such a bad loser or to full of himself/herself when they win. As long as it's not someone like Trip, I will be happy!
 
Rivals that help Ash learn and that prove to be a challenge. Gary never battled Ash until the league so he wasn't a very good one. Paul and TRIP both do this. Paul though seems to overpowered the way he crushed Barry in the league and correct me if I'm wrong, always beat Ash until the league minus their first battle. Trip I like because he has a good non-abusive personality and fights others, which he doesn't always beat. He has also shown to be equal to Ash in their most recent time battling.
 
I would like a girl as a rival who's quirk is to obsess over Ash and crush hard on him, thus trying hard to beat him in battle to imprss him and get him to notice her. Consider the fact that Ash is usually oblivious to Girls having a crush on him but yeah that could be a very interesting rivalry
 
mwto said:
Paul though seems to overpowered the way he crushed Barry in the league and correct me if I'm wrong, always beat Ash until the league minus their first battle.
Click to expand...
IIRC, the two only battled twice; the second time Barry only won because he pitted his starter against a Pokemon that Ash just caught (Gible) - which of course doesn't prove a thing as far as how his skills compare to Ash's.

As for the topic, I generally do favor the generic "snobby personality" rivals who the put the main protagonist down only to then gain more respect for the hero after their last big showdown at a league, etc., but I also prefer originality to their characters. Which is part of the reason I don't find Trip appealing as a rival - he has little to nothing going for him to make him stand out from previous similar rivals like Gary and Paul.
 
Caseydia said:
I really don't care anymore. What they did with Paul was pure gold. Whoever did his story plot needs to come back to the show. All they had to do was tone down the Pokemon abuse and you have a worthy rival.

What they need now is a girl rival(other than Bianca) who would be sort of cold and quiet. Maybe her style of dress could be Lolita meaning she would be mysterious. Does she have to be cruel to Pokemon? No. Insulting the boy's intelligence like Trip is doing is fine by me since he doesn't think at times.
Click to expand...

Diamond_Pearl_Marley.png


this was the first thing i thought of after reading that. and the sad thing is,if Marley stayed with them she could have become a character like that.
 

Attachments

  • Diamond_Pearl_Marley.png
    Diamond_Pearl_Marley.png
    53.8 KB · Views: 124
Maybe someone who helps out Ash throughout his journey, but battles him from time to time. Kinda like Hugh.
 
How about a female character that doesn't suck at battling for once?

Casey, Bianca, Georgia and Burundgly are all shown to be absolutely terrible at battling and lost nearly every battle they were on-screen for. Its amazing how all of Ash's female rivals have been pretty much push-overs.
 
I want a strong, female rival in this series for once.
Someone who battles like Kaede from the Hoenn League, now that was a strong female anime-only trainer I like.
Thinking about it...Saori, a rival of Haruka, was a rival like that as well, the biggest problem however was the lack of an interesting character trait beyond being strong and cool.

Bell could have been the character to combine the best of both worlds but sadly she is portrayed as too weak ( maybe because of her game-self, but the anime is still an exaggeration of that).
I surely don't want another cold and distanced rival like Shinji. Why create a rip-off if they can bring Shinji back anytime they want anyway? As much as I enjoyed the rivalry I think the Seto Kaiba-rival archetype shouldn't be repeated.

Hell, even a bitchy knows-it-all girl would be prefered...Remember how everybody kept calling Nozomi a bitchy rival for no real reason at all? Well, why not make a real one? No tsundere either ( I know it is hard for the anime to create characters who aren't overused archetypes...), just someone who had a hard life and tries to be a Pokémon Master in order to start a better life? Frank Grimes the Pokémon trainer? Why not?
 
Please note: The thread is from 14 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom