What would you think of a pokemon game in 3D

S

Squida

New Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2007
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Seriously this is for a school presentation what would you people think about a pokemon game in 3D meaning something like zelda the ocarina of time and super mario 64. A game with free roam but keeps the Pokemon theme of going around citiies getting badges. What's your opinion??
 
Just like Colosseum and XD, it would suck badly.
This style of camera does not suit to Pokemon. Please, do not give me this crap, NEVER! Pokemon's camera should stay as it is, Diamond and Pearl are enough of a 3D. It is not that they can't have the graphics be better, but another style of a game would NOT be Pokemon.
 
Ash_Pokemaster said:
Just like Colosseum and XD, it would suck badly.
This style of camera does not suit to Pokemon. Please, do not give me this crap, NEVER! Pokemon's camera should stay as it is, Diamond and Pearl are enough of a 3D. It is not that they can't have the graphics be better, but another style of a game would NOT be Pokemon.
Click to expand...

but i mean in a revolutionary way with the new consoles such as the wii and 'possibly' the ps3 and xbox 360 because i think it's time for something new
 
Na.....I disagree with you Squida. But i agree with Ash Pokemaster.
Pokemon Colosseum and XD were the shittest pokemon games ive ever played. i rate them higher the pokemon trading card game which was still dissappointing. Pokemon should just stick to the gameboy. It is the way pokemon was meant to be set out as a game and should stay that way. If it was brought onto the wii or ps3, it would only sell because people would be interested. not because it is a great game
 
people need to move on i mean the original idea is still great and it should stay forever but it's time for Nintendo and Game Freak to come up with somthing that will really put Pokemon on the map for the people who thinks it's a little kids game.
 
I think it would be great if there were a 3D Pokemon game that works like the portable games. Pokemon Colosseum and Pokemon XD were excellent games (contrary to what has been stated here) and I certainly wouldn't mind trying a 3D badge collecting game.
 
Squida said:
but i mean in a revolutionary way with the new consoles such as the wii and 'possibly' the ps3 and xbox 360 because i think it's time for something new
Click to expand...

Right, sometime in the future Nintendo and Sony will be friends
 
Pocket Monsters in 3D would be cool, but they can't make 3D games. Look at Colloseum, the graphics are worse than Stadium and they lack animations for attacks that miss their target, the game is slow and 'squary' and they don't even have sound effects for footsteps when you're waking around. Pokémon would be a great game in 3D . . . if some like SqaureEnix would program it or any one else that can make 3D games.
 
I think a game in 3D could work well, its just that the people at Game Freak would have to put in a lot of work for it.

And as evidenced by the lot of other 3D games they have done in the past, a lot of work is a problem, i.e. their recycled Pokemon models from older games, their stale graphics a good portion of the time, ect.
 
I do agree handled correctly a 3D version of the GBA games would rock.

And I didn't have any major problems with Colloseum or XD, and they definately didn't have worse graphics then Stadium.
 
They did have worse graphics. The colours were different and (this is not about the graphics, more the animations) they DO NOT have animations for attacks that miss the opponent. Also attacks that strikes several times is much slower. In Stadium your pokemon attacked once and your opponent was hit, say, 5 times. In Colloseum you pokemon attacks again between the hits, so that means the camera view have to change several times, causing to take a long time.
But some things are better in Colloseum: the music (I like the battle music very much), the graphic of the animations, the story mode.
I Colloseum and XD did not have worse graphics they had the same graphics as Stadium (at least the pkmn models).
 
Te-em said:
Pocket Monsters in 3D would be cool, but they can't make 3D games. Look at Colloseum, the graphics are worse than Stadium and they lack animations for attacks that miss their target, the game is slow and 'squary' and they don't even have sound effects for footsteps when you're waking around. Pokémon would be a great game in 3D . . . if some like SqaureEnix would program it or any one else that can make 3D games.
Click to expand...

Yer a company like Square Enix would be really good i mean look at kingdom hearts's graphics thats what i meant.
 
Honestly, I like my Pokémon portable. 3D is okay for the spin-offs, but the main series should never be on the Wii/other Nintendo non-handheld console...
 
Yes, Pokémon should remain portable. But DS is capable of 3D graphics. At first I thought the battles in D/P would look like Stadium or something.
 
Squida: There's a game for the Wii. It's called Battle Revolution.

OK, what's with ColoXD hate? I loved those games so much. If you think graphics were not up to par, well, graphics aren't everything (I'd buy games with awful graphics if they have great plot). But why do you hate them so visciously, Angry Man? How can you possibly hate a game involving a flamboyant dancer with a huge afro and a legion of Ludicolos? HOW?!

Anyways, I'm perfectly happy with DS games and stuff. But if they made a 3-D RPG (Which they won't), I'd buy it.
 
I don't get the XD/Colloseum hate either. I keep replaying them, such much easier when you got many memory cards :)

I really don't get why so many people would rather have another Stadium (Battle Revolution) when XD/Collo had multiplayer modes. Not as much as the Stadiums I know, but at least you have the choice. I have the Stadium roms, and it's pretty fun but I got bored quickly. Meh I doubt it's just cos of the rentals.. I just don't have a goal to battle towards.

I'd probably love Battle Revolution if it had a storyline as well as the stuff it has already. I have heard you can't even level up on that, seems pretty useless to me.

A RPG on the Wii would get me to buy a Wii, no second thoughts about that. I'd get BR if it was preowned, which it will be in no time. It sounds like it could be fun for five minutes :S
 
I don't like Colosseum or XD because they are both very linear, compared to pokemon. Yes in pokemon you pretty much have to get the badges and hms in the right order, yes that is true, however there are more places to explore, more things to do, more open spaces to customizing your team.

Now if I were to get a game in 3D similar to the gameboy games then I think it'd need to be in a different engine or set-up to always separate itself from the main games.
 
I wouldn't mind a 3D game that had a similar plot to the original GameBoy/DS RPGs. (Gym badges, HMs, etc.) I think it would be interesting if they tried to incorporate real time battles as well. Where you can make the Pokemon move around to dodge and such. For the moves, they could set something up similar to the Skill Trigger system in .hack//G.U., where they assign each of the four attacks to a certain button.
 
Please note: The thread is from 18 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom