• Hello!

    Please be aware that our content warnings system has recently been updated! Please refer to this thread for more information, or if you're unsure, feel free to contact a Workshop staff member!

    Thank you all for helping us ensure our community is a safe and healthy one, and for your continued patronage in our Library and Workshop.

What's a Fanfiction writer to do?

Srebak

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 26, 2011
Messages
336
Reaction score
134
Over the years, whenever i watched a tv show that i liked, i would almost always come up with ideas for it of my own. Some were good, others were less than original, but i always tried to stay true to the show's continuity so that my story ideas wouldn't seem out of place.

The problem is, the tv shows i liked usually ended up doing things that torpedoed my ideas. Sometimes they showed stories that made mine seem out of place and/or implausible, other times, they beat me to the punch and used story ideas that i had and showed them in a completely different way. A major flaw i have as a writer is that it's not easy for me to change how i write a story, even when i'm told that it would be a good idea (I have issues with change, i admit it), so when either of the above scenarios comes up, i'm usually left at a loss.

Examples:

Teen Titans - I've had numerous ideas for this show, some of them involving new characters, a new villain and the return of other characters (even the reform of a well-known villain). But it felt like, at every turn, the series and/or its comic book sequel were making my ideas impossible or otherwise very unlikely.

Xiaolin Showdown - Like the above show, i've had numerous ideas for this show, but at times, the show itself, and now its sequel show, has done things to make my ideas implausible and that gets pretty dang annoying at times.

Avatar - Once again, i've had numerous ideas for this show in the past, but with the franchise's creators constantly giving out information about the shows, my ideas almost instantly go down the drain, for both Last Airbender and Legend of Korra

Ben 10 - Like the above franchise, this franchise continuously gives out confirmations about its continuity and while it does feel nice to get some in depth information, said information usually torpedoes most of my ideas (Ex. I had plans for a specific couple, but in the end, the franchise broke them up and confirmed that they were done)

Thundercats 2011 - I had plans for a second season when this show ended with only one season. But when i finally got information about what the second season would have been about, it, naturally, torpedoed my own plans.


All of this is just so frustrating, so i ask again; What's a fanfiction writer to do?
 
You don't have to stick to the canon if you don't want to--imagine what would've happened if Event X didn't happen or what another character is doing offstage as the canon is progressing (This is what I'm doing with "Pokemon: The Song of Jewels--a slightly fantastic answer to the question "What was Brock doing while Ash was in Unova?")
 
What such an obvious question......

Fanfic writer is the one who write fan-fictions, whereas fan-fiction is the kind of fictional works written by the fans -- the people who enjoys and admire a piece of fictional work, especially the films, TV shows, games, novels and/or other books, etc.

As long as the fiction contains idea and/or concepts from a canon work, such fiction will be deemed as fanfic. Story plot of fanfic is not only limited to extension of canonical story of canonical characters, but it may also be story of alternative timeline, story of an unknown original character, story set at alternative continuity or even alternative universe, or original story with all these elements included.

So simply speaking, fanfic writers are the ones to create a new story by playing with the already existing fictional ideas. It doesn't matter whether one's fanfic seems out of continuity from the canon or not, because fanfic is not canon after all, and will never be canon (unless so luckily that the canon scenario writer(s) correctly predicts the thought of their fans).



BTW, your frustration seems to be from the fact that canon doesn't follow in the way which you imagined, rather then frustrating over the plot idea of your own fanfic.
My advice: Do not bring your frustration as being an audience of the show towards your fanfic writings. No matter how frustrating the canon becomes, it should not become a frustration over your fanfic. Because fanfic writers are not there to predicts the outcome of the canon.

And if you are speaking of such frustration over the canon materials where it destroys the past ideas, you will definitely not be alone in the Pokemon fandom, especially within the Pokemon fanfic writers specialized in anime-verse, and the shippers.
 
Back
Top Bottom