Which do you prefer plot, and character, wise? GSC or HGSS?

[Somari]

HGSS is far more developed then GSC.

Ten years ago Pokemon games had very basic, and somewhat loose, story-lines. The characters didn't get much driven into their personalities either.

Around the third gen that started changing though. They started paying more attention to the story-line, more attention to characterization, etc.

Due to that fact, some personalities seem different, the storyline is different but follows the same path, etc in the remakes.

 

[The Outrage]

HgSs, we get more insight into the gym leader's lives.

Also, what the heck is with Brock's line "it itches" >_>

Everyone who's read that thought it weird.

 

[Silktree]

Crystal, for having more references to Ecruteak's history and making Ho-Oh and the beasts more captivating. That goes for Eusine, too.

 

[Azure Butterfly]

Silver was better in GSC, but a lot of the characters are more developed in HGSS. The ones that stand out the most are Professor Elm (who actually has a family), and all of the Gym Leaders.

Red is still a mystery though... (I prefer his GSC team, however.)

 

[Falconwing]

HGSS gets deeper into plot and character. So HGSS.

 

[Rоulette Goddess]

gsc.

it's short, simple, and not complex at all.

 

[Whynotnow]

Crystal, for having more references to Ecruteak's history and making Ho-Oh and the beasts more captivating. That goes for Eusine, too.

^

Exactly.

 

[pikachu200]

Silver was better in GSC, but a lot of the characters are more developed in HGSS. The ones that stand out the most are Professor Elm (who actually has a family), and all of the Gym Leaders.

Red is still a mystery though... (I prefer his GSC team, however.)

I never really saw much of a difference between the two teams he had besides Espeon being replaced by a Lapras


But I like HGSS better it had a slightly more added storyline of the rval learning how to train his pokes plus you can battle him again despite his low levels

 

[Smugleaf]

>Pokemon games
>plot

I'm confused.

 

[PlatinumDude]

HG/SS: some of Crystal's elements were implemented into it (like Eusine appearing). Also, the Kimono girls were given a better purpose there, if I remember correctly.

 

[Orion-Sama]

Both are pretty abyssmal, but HGSS added some more spice to the old games, so it wins.

 

[Battaman]

HG/SS: some of Crystal's elements were implemented into it (like Eusine appearing). Also, the Kimono girls were given a better purpose there, if I remember correctly.

Yes, since they had no purpose in gen2 they was given not a better purpose, but rather a purpose at all.
No, being 5 random trainers whit eeveelutions don't make you special.

I like HGSS better, well not Silver character, but that's about it.

 

[Dawn~]

HGSS for sure. I absolutely loved the game. It's amazing.

 

[vee2x_paradox]

When Professor Elm used "" in his email to Professor Oak...

That's it HG/SS >>>> EVERYTHING ELSE EVER

 

[Integration]

When Professor Elm used "" in his email to Professor Oak...

That's it HG/SS >>>> EVERYTHING ELSE EVER

HECK YEAHH.

After I skimmed the email, I had to reread it to make sure I saw it correctly. Haha.

 

[Falconwing]

When Professor Elm used "" in his email to Professor Oak...

That's it HG/SS >>>> EVERYTHING ELSE EVER

That was also in GSC.

 

[Data_Error]

This isn't even a contest. HG/SS expanded enormously upon the original games, and in my opinion it's the best game in the series. The only thing that GSC might have over it is that I like Crystal's design better than Soul's, and I'm not a particular fan of giving Suicune special treatment, but those are personal preferences. HG/SS is head and shoulders above the originals.

 

[pokemoll]

Soulsilver and Heartgold. However i hate the fact there are no contests. I just....grrr!

 

[Cybersai]

HGSS. Both plots weren't much though.

 

[Faye Scarlet]

When Professor Elm used "" in his email to Professor Oak...

It was when I decided I loved the guy. ;A; sob, I never knew he had family in GSC, too...

But overall...hmm, it's a tie between Crystal and HGSS. HGSS is a huge monumental improvement to GS, but Crystal is a third version, and I has a soft spot for all of them. D: Plus, Kris.