Which Elite Four was the hardest?

[Luis92]

What is the hardest Elite Four

I believe it was the Kanto Elite 4 as Hoenn and Johto were walks in the park

can't say anything about Sinnoh know

 

[Æsahættr]

Well, with the types of pokemon the Sinnoh E4 use, their levels, and the type template I usually follow, I think Sinnohs is going to be the most difficult. Johto's E4 was just pitiful.

 

[Luis92]

so since you consider Sinnoh hard,Kanto must be second i assume

 

[phantomness]

I've gotten Pearl in Japanese, so I can confidently say that Sinnoh's Elite Four are the most difficult. I thought Houen was second, Johto was easy and was so was Kanto

 

[xMasterJuicex]

I haven't gotten D/P yet but out of the three Hoenn was the most difficult for me, Kanto was probably the most easy.

 

[Geoffrey]

Kanto the second time around is more difficult than Hoenn in my opinion.

 

[Zeta]

Excluding the "rematch" in Kanto, it would have to be Hoenn, simply because Steven's team of super defensive Pokemon was pretty cheap.

 

[TRF-chan]

Simply going from my childhood memories of tears and frustration...Kanto. Although I didn't have much trouble last week when I fought them. Can't speak for Johto, haven't played it in ages. I'm replaying Hoenn now, but I'm not to that point yet.

 

[Tahnee]

Kanto. Haven't gotten through them on Leaf Green yet...
Johto was SO EASY. Px Although Karen was a bit tough, everyone else... No.

 

[Loch Ness Lapras]

The Hoenn E4 were the hardest for me at first. The Kanto E4 rank second, especially the second time around, although the fact that my team wipes the floor with them every time I battle them now kinda makes them easier. The Johto E4 were EASY AS.

 

[bell02+]

Emerald's Hoenn was one of the hardest. Over all, Sinnoh is probably harder on average... but that wallance! It felt cheap to be him by going through tons of revives and finishing him off with Perish Song (after a ton of tries to get him before)

 

[Bp.]

^ Steven was harder for me to beat than Wallace, which made the Emerald E4 a little easier than the R/S, for me at least.

I have no first hand experince with Sinnoh's, but just looking at the line-up, I think they will be the most difficult...I mean Cynthia looks incredibly strong.

 

[BrainJames]

I say by experience they all are equal. But Johto's is pitiful yet tricky. It introduced like the Sinnoh Elite 4. It introduced that Psychic in the Elite 4. But G/S/C has the most random ever. Psychic, Fighting/Rock, Poison, Dark, and Dragon. But level wise Kanto wins. And difficulty goes to Hoenn due to evil little jerk-wad known as Steven. Not hard, but annoying. I exclude Sinnoh as I have not played the game but it looks difficult.

 

[Jarrod831]

I haven`t yet played DP, but from the looks of it, the Sinnoh E4 will be the hardest. Kanto and Johto were kinda pitiful as i beat them easily at 7 years old or so. Hoen was a bit harder, but it can be made very easy if you go and catch Rayquaza before you challenge them. I just taught it:

-Ice Beam
-Thunderbolt
-Dragon Claw
-Fire blast

Simple special sweeper set and absolutely kills the Hoen E4 in Emerald at lvl. 70

 

[Pokemon_Master_4ever]

The only person in the E4 i could beat fast was Gary in the KANTO version(r/b/y)

 

[AshKetchum]

Kanto was the hardest and Hoenn was the second hardest, Sinnoh was the least...I beat the Sinnoh Elite Four with my highest level pokemon 52 (Snorlax)and the rest were like 50's.

 

[baltor85]

I'm the wierdo who voted for Johto, for one reason alone. Koga's poison types took me by total surprise, and I failed soooo many times, because I kept getting my Pokemon Toxic'd, and his guys kept using Acid Armor. Sure, after I got better at playing the games, Johto was the easiest, but just for the first time through alone, I say Johto.

 

[Captain Shazbot]

I found Sinnoh's Elite Four to be the most difficult one to date, but that's just me.

 

[Turtle Tamer Kammy]

I coulda swore this has been discussed already.

 

[Team Magma Brody]

Well I'd have to say the Kanto Elite Four because I couldn't beat the 3rd Elite Four Fighter.