• The forums' spoiler embargo for all content from Pokémon Legends: Z-A's Mega Dimension DLC has been lifted! Feel free to talk about the new content from the expansion across the forums without the need of spoiler tabs!

    Please note that this lifted embargo only applies for the forums, and may still be in effect on other Bulbagarden sites.

Which Girl companion gave Ash the most trouble?

Which Girl companion gave Ash the most trouble?

  • Misty

    Votes: 24 45.3%

  • May

    Votes: 2 3.8%

  • Dawn

    Votes: 1 1.9%

  • Iris

    Votes: 26 49.1%
  • Total voters
    53
S

Srebak

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 26, 2011
Messages
336
Reaction score
134
Like the title says, which female gave Ash the most trouble?

And by that, i meant which of them gave him the most hurtful remarks, remarks that were less about making him better and more about cutting him down to the point where they were almost doubting if he could be a trainer

I ask this because, looking back, i felt that Misty was a little harsh with Ash and said somethings that could've been taken harshly enough to send Ash home in defeat. And quite frankly, Iris is even worse, her "little kid" comments just make me not like her, especially her comment in the episode with Elgyem, that just sounded harsh and rude

So what do you think
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've moved this to the Grand Festival where it belongs, as its choosing between two or more different entities (in this case, characters).
 
I don't think any of the girls have given him any trouble. It's clear he gets along well with all four of them, and even though Misty and Iris pick on him it never seems to bother him that much. I guess Misty gave him trouble in the beginning with the bike and everything, but that blew over quickly. So I guess if I had to pick one girl it would be Misty, but again, that was only in the very beginning.
 
It has to be Iris. Misty's comments could get cruel from time to time, but Ash genuinely made many ridiculous mistakes during his time in Kanto, so it's somewhat understandable. Iris, on the other hand, needlessly gets on his case for entirely unreasonable and unfair reasons. How would anyone know their way around a region they've never been to before? Why is Ash an immature kid if he doesn't know about every single Pokemon ability? He can't even show enthusiasm about Pokemon or make an innocent remark without receiving a put down from her.
 
What do you mean by, "trouble?" He argued with Misty the most of all the girls, but at the same time they were good friends.

If you mean which female protagonist gave him trouble and the least reason to be traveling with him, I hate to say it, but it probably is Iris. I don't really see her becoming as close with Ash as past girls. Nearly 70 eps into BW and it really doesn't feel like she's impacting his journey in any way.
 
I'm gonna have to vote Kasumi since Iris' role in the franchise hasn't concluded yet. Kasumi seems to be the most violent of all of Satoshi's companions (verbally and physically.) To me, Iris doesn't seem cruel to Satoshi, just very sarcastic.
 
Last edited:
Misty was a b!tch at first, but that didn't last long
May was just a helpless trainer who Ash taught, whereas Misty taught Ash since he was the helpless trainer
Dawn..... eh, I know so little about the DP era, that I can't say
Iris I've heard is a complete b!tch to this day, so I chose her
 
Trouble? I don't know if "trouble" is the proper word here. But anyway, I'm more on the Misty side of things. She just seemed to aggravate him more, and would also bring him physical harm often...early on of course. All Iris really does is say "Kodomo ne", and 85% of the time Ash ignores her. I'm actually surprised Iris is winning this poll...well not really.
 
Zidane said:
Trouble? I don't know if "trouble" is the proper word here. But anyway, I'm more on the Misty side of things. She just seemed to aggravate him more, and would also bring him physical harm often...early on of course. All Iris really does is say "Kodomo ne", and 85% of the time Ash ignores her. I'm actually surprised Iris is winning this poll...well not really.
Click to expand...

Probably because "trouble" is not well-defined here. It could mean anything really.
 
I guess "trouble" in this context would mean which girl seemed to annoy or upset Ash the most. In which case, it's a no brainer: it's Misty. Iris may seem to be putting him down more often for the most unjustified of things, but Ash seldom reacts to it and the odd time he does, it's hardly spectacular. Ash almost always reacted to Misty's comments. Hence you could say he was "troubled" by them.
 
Misty or Iris, but gotta go with Misty

but still
Kanto Misty = bonafide jackass
OI/Johto and beyond Misty = sweetheart
 
I dont think any girl Ash traveled with gave him exactly "trouble". Sure he had dissidence with some of them and they didnt always get along but you could tell how Ash was very good friend with Misty,My or Dawn,. With Iris its too soon to comment, though judging by what i saw so far they dont seem close as much like it was case with her predecessors.

However if i would really have to choose despite question being undefined(in what sense trouble?) i would probably say Misty. She argued with Ash the most,being quite critic and liking to rib him at times. But more often than not this just served as motivation to push Ash forward as trainer and learn on mistakes đ,when he was rookie being actually beneficial.

Only time when she crossed the line was probably when physically abusing him but since Ash was idiot who had no clue about nothing this was justified.Who wouldnt be pissed of after someone fries your bike,never pays it back and continue to do idiotic mistakes ignoring your advice?

Besides that didnt last long,with Misty becoming more amicable toward Ash when they strengthened friendship,and while they still argued at times and she continued to tease him,disagreements were never so scenical to annoy Ash to some deeper degree.

Yankees4life said:
but still
Kanto Misty = bonafide jackass
OI/Johto and beyond Misty = sweetheart
Click to expand...

There is some truth in it,though im not sure if i would use such description.While Misty was more violent in Kanto days,i still wouldnt call her exactly "sweetheart"being all sunny and happy in OI,Johto and beyond that(Hoenn).She was more playful and out going,but she was always tomboyish and spirited liking to criticize.
 
Misty. She was bossy and braggy and a snobby nosy girl just following Ash around to get him pay her bike back.
 
Misty, because I think Iris kind of makes fun of Ash in a playful way. Not Misty though. She just seemed to be rude towards Ash at the beginning.
 
Misty for sure. Iris may be mean, but she doesn't really give Ash any "trouble". I mean, Misty kept nagging a ten year old about getting her a new bike. If that isn't considered more "trouble" than Iris just being sarcastic, then I suppose I don't understand the meaning of "trouble".
 
I just have to say, in Ash's defense, the only character flaw i could see in Season one was his EGO, and who could blame him? If Gary wasn't always acting superior to him, maybe he would've turned out more humbler.
 
Well, on the one hand I think that Pokéshipping has a crazy fanbase sometimes, to the point that it was fought over on the internet, but it's cuter than...

Oh, wait, sorry. Wrong kind of thread.

Well, for most abusive females I'd have to go with Bayleef. I mean, she was always tackling him and wanted to perch on his shoulder and all that, am I right? Or maybe I'd go with Latias, who was obviously just toying with his feelings and probably kicks puppies for breakfast.

Now, it's too early to say whether Iris or Misty was worse. On the one hand, Misty constantly beat him up and nagged him for that bike of hers and lugged around the Togepi of doom. On the other hand, Iris has constantly mocked him and has been xenophobic and won't stop calling him a kid for doing anything from making a simple mistake to playing the wrong level of Angry Birds on Cilan's iPhone. All in all, I'd have to go with Brock for running away and breaking Ash's heart and/or having the personality of cardboard it's too early to say, and I'm a bit too biased towards Misty at the moment to actually vote in a poll.
 
Misty. 'Nuf said.

Although I haven't seen B/W yet, so I haven't seen Iris yet either.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom