Which Old Pokemon do you want to Return in Daimond and Pearl (if any)

B

bell02+

when you need more, have+
Joined
Jan 1, 2003
Messages
2,876
Reaction score
0
Just as the title states it. I guess we can assume that both Diamond and Pearl may not include all of the monsters from the previous generations. So which monsters do you want to return, and if a legendary (or if you just want to) explain why (Personally I think Legendaries should have a relivant story or purpose, so if someone like Mew/Celebi returns, it should have a reason).


For me I'd want My Favorites to return, but others more for setting purposes:
Sandshrew (its been in every pkmn game, its bound to be other people's favorites/popular. It also would be cool for a new evo or pre-evo... but I probably wouldn't use it either way)
Cacnea, and Trapinch People like Flygon, I like Cacturne, but in reality, it'd be cool to have another desert, maybe a larger one that is complicated to navagate.
Stabyle I just think this monster is cool, and a cool looking Evo would even be better.
Wingull I like pokemon by the sea so it'd be cool.
Farfeth'd I think it would be cool for an evolution of F.F., like my brother said, a samurai would be cool. Though, I'd probably want a mallard duck also. Personally I think a soilder would be a more proper evolution (because Farfetch'd is already like a samurai)
Wailmer because it looks like it should have whales, actually a lighthouse would be cool also.
I also want a return of all of the common feild monsters.. they'd bring viraity to areas.

Personally though... although impossible... I think it would be very cool to be able to catch an old starter wild. I know I'm not the only person to wonder where they are from. But, this would seriously screw with game balance.

So, Which monsters do you want to see return?
 
Last edited:
well, i would love to see ALL of the legendaries in the game. perhaps after you beat the elite 4, and then some other side quests, have an island open up, you could have an amazing storyline (why else would ALL the legendaries be there) and be able to capture them all.
 
D/P will have its own set of starters. As for any of the previous starters becoming available after the E4, who knows. In any case, you can still trade them over from the third gen. Anyway, I'm not sure which ones will make it into the Shinou dex. I hope some of the third gen pokes manage to get in, although the second gen is really what needs support right now. A large amount of the first gen pokes always seem to show up in some fashion.
 
Just basic common ones, like gastly and ratatta. Stuff like that.

And please, I beg them to stay consistant with pokemon locations. No wobbuffet in fields and no marill in ponds. I guess I can accept those cause they already made that mistake once. But no knew mistakes. Like if a pokemon was rare in one game, it shouldn't be everywhere in another. Or if it was in a cave, it shouldn't be in a field. Etc.
 
I think Wobbuffet was in a feild because Safari Zones aren't suppose to be natural feilds. I think it's implied that the park owners catch monsters and put them in there, like a zoo, amusement park, or safari adventure park thing.

Also.. I don't know about many legendaries and game balance, I guess it could be super hidden like in FR/LG/E. Maybe it'd be cool though if there was a new character in the game that can give you a mysterious egg (or egg with a legendary in it), You'd have to figure out which pokemon it is (by going to another person to give a clue... maybe an old lady as a breeding psychic or something ) then have to go on a quest in a special area where you could find out more about the monster to make it hatch... Maybe its too much work, but I really want a lot of exploration in the game.
 
I want something like Yellow, where you have a chance to get the starters from people, as opposed to choosing one if we get all the starters.
Eevees for definites. Hopefully with quicker breeding (because unless you use Ditto the breeding machine, which doesn't give the greatest stats, it takes forever in the Daycare, and the egg takes longer. ¬¬) or chances to get more than one.
Skarmory
Taillow/Swellow
Meowth and Persian
Anything with Pickup. Hehe. XD
I do not want to see the Tentas. Gah. I hate Surfing because of them.
Don't want to see Luvdisc either. Actually, I'd like them to tone down all the waters. Fair enough it's 70% of the Earth, but JESUS!
 
Like if a pokemon was rare in one game, it shouldn't be everywhere in another.
Click to expand...

Why not? In real life an animal can be very common in one area, but live in others while being more rare. I think that makes perfect sense.
 
Let's see. A few I would have listed are already confirmed.
Confirmed:
All the Nidoran family
Scyther
Scizor
Pichu
Pikachu
Raichu
Geodude
Graveler
Golem
Zubat
Golbat
Crobat
Magikarp
Gyarados
Tentacool
Tentacruel
Wooper
Quagsire
Snorlax
Sudowoodo
Sneasel
Roselia
Elekid
Electabuzz
Mr. Mime
Mantine
Caterpie
Metapod
Butterfree
34 already? Wowzers. Feel free to contribute to this list if you find any others.
But, back on topic. I'd like Remoraid and Octillery, Dunsparce, Taillow, Spheal, Snorunt, Gulpin, Swalot, Heracross, Aron family, Jiggly family, Gastly family, Trapinch & co., and Wobbuffet. But not Eevee.
EDIT: By the way, I put Zubat, Magikarp, and Tentacool there because it's a tradition that will not be broken.
 
Infinite Sceptile said:
By the way, I put Zubat, Magikarp, and Tentacool there because it's a tradition that will not be broken.
Click to expand...

DON'T FORGET THE MIGHTY GOLDEEN!
 
Eevee, eevee, and MORE EEVEE.
Plus I would like a chance to catch the Legendary Dogs. -Suicune fan-
 
I'd like to be able to catch Pikachu, Ponyta/Rapidash, Mew, Dratini/Dragonair/Dragonite, Charmander (if they put the original starters in the wild), Eevee, and Oddish/Gloom/Vileplume/Bellosoum. I would love to be able to have a storyline with all of the legendaries in it too.
 
Roses Ablaze said:
How are these confirmed?
Click to expand...
All the Nidoran family-unsure
Scyther-related to Scizor
Scizor-shown to showcase male/female differences
Pichu-related to Pikachu
Pikachu-Shown battling in a screenshot
Raichu-related to Pikachu
Geodude-shown battling Bouysel
Graveler-related to Geodude
Golem-related to Geodude
Zubat-he said cause they always are
Golbat-Related to Zubat
Crobat-^^
Magikarp-he said cause they always are
Gyarados-related to Gyrados
Tentacool-he said cause they always are
Tentacruel-related to Tentacool
Wooper-shown to showcase male/female differences
Quagsire-related to Wooper
Snorlax-new prevo
Sudowoodo-new prevo
Sneasel-new evo
Roselia-new evo
Elekid-just a guess on the new pokemon that looks like Electabuzz
Electabuzz-just a guess on the new pokemon that looks like Electabuzz
Mr. Mime-new prevo
Mantine-new prevo
Caterpie-related to Butteree
Metapod-related to Butteree
Butterfree-shown to showcase male/female differences
 
I'd like to see Eevee, Skitty, Meowth, Absol, many of the Johto Pokemon including Hoothoot, Misdreavus, and Teddiursa (the GSC era was my favorite, so I was disappointed that most of the Johto Pokemon were either only obtainable in Colosseum/XD or in Emerald's Safari Zone), and since I'm a devout Legendary Beast fan, it's required that I wish for one or all three of the 'Beasts. X3 Suicune especially. But since they are obtainable in both Colosseum and FR/LG, I doubt that would happen.
 
Please note: The thread is from 20 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom