which one will u pick?

[Ararararagi-san]

In HgSs,which will be you're starter? if u want you can even post you're "team"!!

I'm torn between Cyndaquil+chicorita

 

[Sketch]

I don't know if we need another HGSS discussion topic...

 

[Evil Raichu]

There are a lot of them. Oh well.

I'm really having trouble deciding. At first I was determined to pick Totodile, since in the original games I never chose him. But then I was thinking, perhaps I should pick Cyndaquil, depending on whether or not you can catch Growlithe or evolve it before you get to Kanto, or if they don't make Houndour available pre-E4.

And I'm just having trouble resisting my outright favorite, Chikorita.

It really depends on the pokemon available. I wish there was a way I could play with all three.

 

[Tina]

I don't know if we need another HGSS discussion topic...

Exactly.

If you want to talk about HGSS, go here or here. Trying to keep the HGSS threads to a minimum here.

 

[Fig]

Assuming the pokemon available don't change, Cyndaquil, for a team of Cyndaquil, Espeon, Ampharos, Lapras, Gengar, HM Slave.

If there are changes to availability and Houndoom is available early, Chikorita, for Chikorita, Espeon, Houndoom, Lapras, Gengar, HM Slave.

 

[Magmaster12]

Chicoria has a terrible moveset along with being very weak to the gyms and base stat wise

totodile is more of a attacker whitch is still an issue due to lack of physical water moves

so I guess I'll chose cyndaquil

 

[Force Fire]

totodile.

 

[Charizards Burn]

yea im going to go with totadile again.

I did waaay back in gold and im going to get him again in HG

 

[Kiratwig]

Chikorita I always get grass first

 

[Falconwing]

Cyndaquil. No contest whatsoever (unless pokemon contest are thrown in)

 

[TTEchidna]

Is this seriously even a question you have to ask me of all people?

But I'm gonna import SS. And start with Chikorita. Yeah that's right. I'm saving Cyndaquil for HeartGold in English so I can play it like I did ten years ago.

 

[Megaboom]

I'm going to choose Cyndaquil. Not too sure about team because I'm pretty sure some Pokemon locations will change. Probably going to go with four Johtos, one Kanto, and an HM slave.

 

[Olaf-symbiote]

I picked Totodile in Gold, so naturally I'll be picking it in Heart Gold.

 

[Some_Gamer_Dude]

I'll probably go:
Gold-Chikorita(M)
Soul-Cyndaquil(F)

Then trade my Diamond for a Totodile... unless the manual defaults have changed.

 

[Yoshi-san]

Totodile FTW!

 

[DCM]

I will be starting with Totodile. He's a great pokemin anyways.

 

[s|ush]

Cyndaquil in HG and Totodile in SS. Then a third play through for Chikorita no doubt.

 

[Gligar13]

Cyndaquil, it rocks and can make the game way easier.

 

[dman_dustin]

I'll probably choose Totodile, since it my favorite Johto Starter. I have nothing against Cyndaquil or Chikorita and if Pokemon were real I'd probably be happy with whoever I get, but I'm going with Totodile.

 

[Zephy]

I want HeartGold and my starter will be Cyndaquil no question. It's too cute!