Who would win in these battles: the three girls

M

MistyBrockAsh

New Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2008
Messages
296
Reaction score
0
in the series we have had misty, may, and dawn


if they all battled eachother 3 on 3 or 6 on 6 who would be victorious and why

misty vs may
misty vs dawn
dawn vs may
 
I'd say Misty. One, she's a gym leader and has plenty of Battle Experience. Two, the other girls are coordinators and can make a battle flashy, but can they fight effectively?

There's a picture somewhere of this. I need to find it again. I accidentally deleted it.
 
Misty vs. May/Dawn: Misty (because she has had more experience as a trainer than both of them)

Dawn vs. May: Uh...May? (Dawn beat her in the Wallace Cup)
 
Misty would probably have the best chance. She is a gym leader so she has more experience with battling.

But that doesn't mean Dawn or May can't win. Co-ordinators aren't just all glamour and beauty. They're shown to be great battlers too. And the move combinations make for a big punch.
 
May would have a decent shot, having won several to the majority of her contests by way of knockout. Of course, that's usually discouraged, but then again the favorite being a Poor Predictable Rock kind of evens the odds a little. I think if either coordinator got close, though, some rabid loony would storm TV Tokyo.
 
May then a close defeat for Misty by Dawn.

May>Dawn>Misty in terms of Pokemon and diversity. Both by far on the second one than Misty. Plus I wonder if Dawn's Togekiss would give mind tricks to Misty...
 
Misty may have her so-called Gym Experience, but how much battling does she do now that she's put on a bus? D: We never see, so we can't tell. Plus she has all water Pokemon, and May's and Dawn's teams are far more diverse.

If I'm being unbiased against Misty (sort of), I'd say May and Dawn will stand a good chance against her, and will either beat her just barely, or get defeated.
 
As much as I think Misty could kick there butts, May seems to have an advantage with her Venusaur and Blaziken against the other girl's Pokemon.

I don't think Dawn would stand a chance though against either of them in a full out brawl. Misty with her Gyarados would dominate, and her other Pokemon seem to be pretty tough thanks to being gym Pokemon.
 
I think May could beat both Misty and Dawn.
She's got so much skills in contests and learned battling moves from Ash.
I think she could take it. Dawn's still a bit of a newbie compared to her.
 
I think May could beat both Misty and Dawn.
She's got so much skills in contests and learned battling moves from Ash.
I think she could take it. Dawn's still a bit of a newbie compared to her.
 
I say misty. she has all her gym experience, and each of them only have 1 pokemon super effective to hers. May has her Venasaur, but since it is part poison type, has a nice weakness to misty's phsycic pokemon, starmie. And may's pachirisu is just that. A tiny squirrel, with it's best stat being its speed, and its worst being tied between attack and special attack. I wouldn't be able to do anything to misty's pokemon before it gets crushed.
 
Misty's really only got one type and that's water. If May's Beautifly used Giga Drain or something, Misty would be done for.
 
I want to say Misty, but I think May would be able to beat her since she'd have a pretty good type advantage in Venusaur. Without it, though, I'd say Misty would win hands down. I think both could beat Dawn at this point. She's too focused on coordinating to battle.
 
Dawn would easily lose since her pokemon are all not evolved, Misty would win but May has a Venasaur...but I ithnk she'd win :)
 
I'm going to have to say Misty in regards to true battles. The fact is that, regardless of whether she is a Gym Leader or not, Misty's more experienced than May or Dawn by about five to six years, even if May and Dawn ended up becoming battlers instead of coordinators. The fact that May and Dawn are coordinators is also enough reason to believe that they won't be able to really have much of a chance to beat Misty, as the concepts are fundamentally different. I would also like to point out that May having a Venusaur and a Blaziken isn't proof that she'll beat Misty, as I must remind you that having an evolution=/=beating trainers. Need I really remind you that Skitty defeated a Dusclops in one of the contest battles, Misty's Corsola defeated a Gyarados, not to mention several of Ash's wins in Kanto and Johto.

However, when it comes to Contest Battles, May and Dawn might be more than capable of at least getting toe-to-toe with Misty, as Misty did technically partook in a Pokemon Contest before (Princess Festival Contest)
 
If we go by what we've been shown on the show, then the girl who actually has partaken in the most battles, even if you discount contest battles, is actually Dawn by a very comfortable margin (and DP's not over...) she's had great runs in the Hearthome tag team tournaments, she participated in the Twinleaf festival and actually had a fair amount of actual official double battles with Ash. So, I would actually give the advantage to Dawn, since she's got a balanced team (Pachirisu covers the water types) and she's already beaten May... I think Dawn would do great against Misty, but would strugle against May.

Now between Misty and May, Misty has been shown in more regular battles than May, but May's contest style was always more battly than contesty. May's team is also more balanced including a fully evolved grass starter so I would give a slight edge to May.

so...

Dawn v Misty: slight edge to Dawn
Dawn v May: Regular battle I might give May a slight edge, contest battle, Dawn comfortably
May v Misty: slight edge to May.
 
Misty just seems better at battling to me, besides, i just cant See May or Dawn getting past Misty's Gyarados, theyd get annihilated.
 
Misty would beat both of them, and Dawn would beat May (in fact, she DID beat May)
 
misty_vs_may_and_dawn_by_mauroz.jpg

Here's the aforementioned picture.

I still stand by it.
 
I always hear how misty has experience because she is a gym leader and all but I have never really ,not even once, seen her to be all that powerful of a trainer. In the original series she would mostly win by luck and less by skill.Because of this I honestly think May or Dawn could beat her very easily as soon as they get past that Gyarados.(which should not be too hard because they both have powerhouses as well.)If it was may against Dawn I feel that Dawn would win most likely because now she has a Mamoswine and a Togekiss.

So Like this:

Misty vs Dawn/May= Dawn/May
May vs Dawn= Dawn by a little bit.
 
Please note: The thread is from 15 years ago.
Please take the age of this thread into consideration in writing your reply. Depending on what exactly you wanted to say, you may want to consider if it would be better to post a new thread instead.
Back
Top Bottom