Mafia One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - ENDGAME - Baroque Works Win!!!

[Flashranite]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 2: Over-doped

also, sorry guys, for not being around, I had some net troubles the last 2 days and failed to make it online

I don't believe the cop (if there it's one) would communicate with anyone but tonight's target.

Since we haven't heard anything about a cop I assume two things.
1) there is no cop
2) the cop is mafia and found mafia.
As for why I think if the cop was town we would of already heard of them. If they are mafia then there is no reason to speak till you find one of their own.

I do not agree and

I still think there's likely two Cops, one for each alignment. It makes sense set up wise.

I think this makes most sense to me as well. I do think the factions are very equally divided this game, with both factions having equal or close to equal powers

@AussieEevee; And what if there is a strongman? I doubt mafia need to communicate to know to use it to take out the cop.

so, you think the Boroque Works killer is a stronman too?
What would be the point of having the Enchantress role then?

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

@AussieEevee; no my "gloating" means nothing beacuse:
A. it wasn't gloating
B. I was planning on typing that post anytime I felt like it, but did it right away, so the speed doesn't matter
C. I ALWAYS have hunches day 1 and switch to reads night 1, it's how I roll irl and in mafia
D. like EVERYONE else has said, being "scummy" means nothing in the game as the mafia is equal to town in numbers and doesn't know who they are and I don't even know how the NK works because of that.
E. I would've outright committed a scummy act to throw the game, because I HATE being a mafia member.
if you don't provide any REAL basis soon, I have no choice than to OMGUS.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

I have no idea what that means, but i have provided enough reason for lynching you.

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

no, you haven't

 

[HumanDawn]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

@returnofmastercrazyhand; @AussieEevee;

What do you think of the votes on me and Flashranite?

that comment that mch would commit an outright scummy act if he's mafia worries me for future games

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

and before you say one more time I'm scummy, READ THE OP CARFULLY.
if not, then I will vote you for incessantly focusing on ONE LITTLE DETAIL, let alone one without solid evidence that it's incriminating. you should be looking for someone who pretty much has slipped up more than once, like yourself.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

no, you haven't

Sure have. 1) self vote. 2) Quick to point out that you didn't vote poke man. 3) I am certain you are not on my faction.

Also, if scum doesn't mean anything, then confirm your faction and role.

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

@returnofmastercrazyhand; @AussieEevee;

What do you think of the votes on me and Flashranite?
that comment that mch would commit an outright scummy act if he's mafia worries me for future games

I said something similar in chaos mafia, so I'm telling the truth

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

you should be looking for someone who pretty much has slipped up more than once, like yourself.

I haven't slipped up at all. I changed my thoughts on the Lovandra vote situation. That is all.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

@returnofmastercrazyhand; @AussieEevee;

What do you think of the votes on me and Flashranite?

that comment that mch would commit an outright scummy act if he's mafia worries me for future games

I have no real read on Flash to be honest, but I am 99% convinced you are on the same side as me.

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

no, you haven't

Sure have. 1) self vote. 2) Quick to point out that you didn't vote poke man. 3) I am certain you are not on my faction.

Also, if scum doesn't mean anything, then confirm your faction and role.

I have already pointed out that I was joking and joke votes/self votes are common here. and I most definitely debunked you little "speed at gloating" thing in my post with 5 points in it.
and I don't want o public claim because I don't know how the NK works, my idea is that each member gets a chance each night, but becase they don't know their own teammates, they could easily kill another mafia.
I'll pm you my role

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

no, you haven't

Sure have. 1) self vote. 2) Quick to point out that you didn't vote poke man. 3) I am certain you are not on my faction.

Also, if scum doesn't mean anything, then confirm your faction and role.

I have already pointed out that I was joking and joke votes/self votes are common here. and I most definitely debunked you little "speed at gloating" thing in my post with 5 points in it.
and I don't want o public claim because I don't know how the NK works, my idea is that each member gets a chance each night, but becase they don't know their own teammates, they could easily kill another mafia.
I'll pm you my role

PMng is fine.

It might be common, but that doesn't mean I have to like it.

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

just sent the pm containing my role, my faction is straw hats
I think because of 7 mafia and 7 town, my role is also used on the mafia's side

 

[ReturnofMCH]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

no, you haven't

Sure have. 1) self vote. 2) Quick to point out that you didn't vote poke man. 3) I am certain you are not on my faction.

Also, if scum doesn't mean anything, then confirm your faction and role.

I have already pointed out that I was joking and joke votes/self votes are common here. and I most definitely debunked you little "speed at gloating" thing in my post with 5 points in it.
and I don't want o public claim because I don't know how the NK works, my idea is that each member gets a chance each night, but becase they don't know their own teammates, they could easily kill another mafia.
I'll pm you my role

PMng is fine.

It might be common, but that doesn't mean I have to like it.

jokes never reveal info, especially self-joke votes
it's the serious day 1 bandwagons that reveal info.

 

[Snowy]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

Yes... Bandwagons. Quite a few people yelled at me for assuming something regarding the early bandwagon.

Either way, I'll do this... for now: Unvote: MCH

Spoiler

I'll vote a little later then.

 

[Flashranite]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

so, MCH, why do you feel the necessity to defend yourself from only one vote?

 

[Life]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

Spoiler

1. @HumanDawn;
3. @jackatlasred;
4. @jokool;
5. @CrackFox;
6. @returnofmastercrazyhand;
7. @Zexy;
8. @Flashranite;
10. @AussieEevee;
11. @lovandra;
13. @Midorikawa;
14. @Momoka;
15. @Emolga;

Mid-day vote count:

The Voted	Voter(s)
Flashranite (II)	HumanDawn, CrackFox
HumanDawn (II)	lovandra, jackatlasred
No Vote (IIX)	jokool, returnofmastercrazyhand, Zexy, Flashranite, Emolga, AussieEevee, Mdorikawa, Momoka

The phase will end in a little less than 24 hours.​

@Emolga; There hasn't been a post from you since Night 1. You have until the end of this phase (Day 3) to make a post or else you'll be subbed out. If you do need to be subbed out, let me know, please + thanks.

 

[jackatlasred]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

I find people who are more ambiguous to be more mafia right now.

 

[Midorikawa]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

I don't know who to vote for at this point, but I think zexy and midorikawa are town so far.

Why? What defines us as town? How do you know it’s not an act to destroy you townies from the inside!?

Theorycrafting, but I would rather silence MCH than you if i had that power.

So you either want an easy lynch or you view him as a larger threat than me. Is that why you want to lynch him so bad?

Pressure away. I can't read your mind to know what answers you expect.

…..What do you think pressure is for?

Also just because you claim not to be something doesn't mean you aren't. Someone could guess me as a doctor and I could say I'm not and still could be. Denial is a way of protection in mafia.

I have read the strategy guides.

…Point? Strategy guides are bs in actual games. Strategy guides can’t predict players actions or thoughts, especially with a group of different personalities.

Used the right way any vote can lead to information, serious or joke.

So what does a self vote tell you then?

For starters it usually means someone isn’t afraid of a few votes.

AussieEevee seems to be going way too into ROMCH's early joke vote, and that still baffles me. Joke votes/self votes are very common around here on day one, so I don't know why this would be any different...

Doesn't mean I have to like them. MCH is pretty scummy though... but I have no idea why everyone is voting Flopunny.

Scummy? What’s scummy?” Has it not been established plenty enough that there is no scummy or townie in this game?

Also everyone not AE: Note that they used scummy.

Statements like "MCH is scummy" are strange this game.
The scum don't know each other, and as a result, which lynches they have to push.
The town is pretty much faced with the same situation.
So what is "scummy" supposed to mean in this game?

It means that

1) MCH was caught doing an anti-town action. Self voting/joke voting.
2) He was very quick to gloat that he didn't vote for Poke Man.

My guess is that the mafia players have all located eachother before Poke Man's lynch. Lovandra's claim would have made that easy.

Either way, it is after 9am (1 GMT) so votes are locked. It doesn't matter what I think untiil after the update

1) Is that your way of implying you are town?
2) Point?
3) If mafia knew who each other were then in no way would one have been nightkilled. Poke Man was lynched DAY ONE. A BW member was nightkilled NIGHT ONE. Unless it was a non-mafia kill, then that makes absolutely zero sense as to why they would purposely put themselves on equal ground as town. And what is the point of that statement? How does it relate to MCH?

I think my words were "Anti-town"... I didn't use the word "scummy" for the joke votes. The way I see it, they are useless. They don't get discussions going, they don't tell us anything.

And how quick you were to gloat means a lot in the grand scheme of things.

Spoiler

And this is why I said remember folks. AE you did call him scummy for it. Just look back up. That’s contradictory!

Hmm... not a bad choice, and not that surprising. I think alt of us saw that coming.

Why do you say that? I didn’t see it coming. What made her more likely over some of us other people?

Interesting. That means both sides are even again. This looks like it'll be a close game

Vote:MCH

Why? And Please give a reason that isn’t just because he gloated and self voted. AKA a reason that we can actually care to vote him for.

I still sick and have no idea right now. For now.

VOTE: HUMAN DAWN

Why?

what did i do

or didn't

Cause you r good. I obviously dont want you as enemy :3. *read hard to do now cause everyone keep on silence*

Also I, for now have no idea who should I vote...

1) Wouldn’t you not want to lynch him then this way if he’s on your side he’s useful?
2) So why are you voting Human?

Vote: humandawn

Well lov has been wrong before so I'll go with Her on this.

What? Explain please.

@HumanDawn; not really but I still have no read on you and was gonna vote for you anyways.
@CrackFox; final arcadia was not really afraid to lynch, and was not afraid to take chances. Even if she was mafia it was dangerous in this game for mafia to keep her.

Why not vote someone you have a read on?
Also the way you described FA is half the players in this game.

@AussieEevee; no my "gloating" means nothing beacuse:
A. it wasn't gloating
B. I was planning on typing that post anytime I felt like it, but did it right away, so the speed doesn't matter
C. I ALWAYS have hunches day 1 and switch to reads night 1, it's how I roll irl and in mafia
D. like EVERYONE else has said, being "scummy" means nothing in the game as the mafia is equal to town in numbers and doesn't know who they are and I don't even know how the NK works because of that.
E. I would've outright committed a scummy act to throw the game, because I HATE being a mafia member.
if you don't provide any REAL basis soon, I have no choice than to OMGUS.

A) Doesn’t make it any less uneccessary
B) Why did you feel a need to say something?
C) And what if those hunches are wrong?
D) …………………………………….

Just go look at the top where you called me and Zexy town. You can’t say something like this when you were just pulling the same stuff yourself.
E) There is this thing called subbing out. Doing that is playing against your win condition which is a serious offense.
F) OMGUS? Are you really that threatened by AE’s one vote? Is OMGUS really what you bring yourself to do rather than ignoring them?

I have no idea what that means, but i have provided enough reason for lynching you.

No you haven’t. You have provided nothing convincing. When attempting to lynch someone you want provide reasoning to get others to join in. You have provided nothing.

no, you haven't

And you have not provided any reason not to in this game.

@returnofmastercrazyhand; @AussieEevee;

What do you think of the votes on me and Flashranite?

that comment that mch would commit an outright scummy act if he's mafia worries me for future games

You and me both.

and before you say one more time I'm scummy, READ THE OP CARFULLY.
if not, then I will vote you for incessantly focusing on ONE LITTLE DETAIL, let alone one without solid evidence that it's incriminating. you should be looking for someone who pretty much has slipped up more than once, like yourself.

This is worse than AE’s reasoning.

no, you haven't

Sure have. 1) self vote. 2) Quick to point out that you didn't vote poke man. 3) I am certain you are not on my faction.

Also, if scum doesn't mean anything, then confirm your faction and role.

…………….This is just getting sad.

you should be looking for someone who pretty much has slipped up more than once, like yourself.

In what way did they slip up?

you should be looking for someone who pretty much has slipped up more than once, like yourself.

I haven't slipped up at all. I changed my thoughts on the Lovandra vote situation. That is all.

……………………………………………………….

@returnofmastercrazyhand; @AussieEevee;

What do you think of the votes on me and Flashranite?

that comment that mch would commit an outright scummy act if he's mafia worries me for future games

I have no real read on Flash to be honest, but I am 99% convinced you are on the same side as me.

Why?

I have already pointed out that I was joking and joke votes/self votes are common here. and I most definitely debunked you little "speed at gloating" thing in my post with 5 points in it.
and I don't want o public claim because I don't know how the NK works, my idea is that each member gets a chance each night, but becase they don't know their own teammates, they could easily kill another mafia.
I'll pm you my role

PMng is fine.

It might be common, but that doesn't mean I have to like it.

There is so many things wrong with these two quotes.

just sent the pm containing my role, my faction is straw hats
I think because of 7 mafia and 7 town, my role is also used on the mafia's side

……………………………………………………..NK Mafia member. Kill this guy. He’s so adamant on being town so he’s obviously an enemy. Plus most roles shared between the factions are big ones like tracker, roleblocker, etc. Which means all the more reason for mafia to NK you.

Yes... Bandwagons. Quite a few people yelled at me for assuming something regarding the early bandwagon.

Either way, I'll do this... for now: Unvote: MCH

Spoiler

I'll vote a little later then.

Why? Is this implying you are town and on the same side as him?

I find people who are more ambiguous to be more mafia right now.

Are you implying that you are town? Who do you find to be ambiguous?


I’m not sure who I find more lynchable. MCH who overreacts to a single vote, and attempts to get it off by threatening OMGUS, or AE who just provides bad reasoning and insists on it being good. Plus what I said last phase. Not to mention both are contradictory.

Also in case anyone is wondering why I’ve been silent for a bit. Work. I was busy with work and sleep so I haven’t been on because work is exhausting and always busy for me.


VOTE: MCH

Because at least AE is providing something, and currently I find your posts to be the least useful in general to both sides.

 

[jackatlasred]

Re: One Piece: Alabasta Mafia - Day 3: Gone With Grace

I have found the person I have voted for the most ambiguous now.