• Hey Trainers! Be sure to check out Corsola Beach, our newest section on the forums, in partnership with our friends at Corsola Cove! At the Beach, you can discuss the competitive side of the games, post your favorite Pokemon memes, and connect with other Pokemon creators!
  • Due to the recent changes with Twitter's API, it is no longer possible for Bulbagarden forum users to login via their Twitter account. If you signed up to Bulbagarden via Twitter and do not have another way to login, please contact us here with your Twitter username so that we can get you sorted.

Mafia Portal Mafia: Endgame, Now Under New Management

Reader mode
Jinjo said:
Doesn't a Bodyguard die when it successfully protects its target at night?
Click to expand...
That is true. However, I am not dead.

Which only proves my theory that protecting Aussie was a pointless move on my part.

'Course, it's possible that the mafia chose not to act on Night 2. A small possibility but a possibility nonetheless.
 
Jinjo said:
Doesn't a Bodyguard die when it successfully protects its target at night?
Click to expand...

oof yeah, that's a big thing for me to forget. There has to be a doctor then? or are they really just these protective roles?
 
If I may ask, why's the idea of there being both a doctor and a bodyguard so strange?
 
I think I was in a mafia with both roles before (at least, two protective roles).
 
BackSet said:
'Course, it's possible that the mafia chose not to act on Night 2. A small possibility but a possibility nonetheless.
Click to expand...
Not killing every night is a really bizarre move since it usually goes against their wincon and I feel like it would only be done if they wanted to mislead the doctor into clearing a scum as if it were a NK target.

Which is ridiculously risky since they can’t predict who the doctor is going to target.
 
Then there must be both a doctor and a bodyguard. Or some other protector role.
 
Day 3 Vote Count

Max1996- (2) (Space, Backset)
Backset- (2) (Snake, Max)
TheCapsFan- (1) (Jinjo)

Day ends on Monday the 16th at 8 pm CDT. With 10 alive it takes 6 to reach majority.
 
Or there's a town roleblocker...
Wait, roleblocker doesn't block kills for you all usually do they? Because they do on zd.

I'll have to think over the claims and everything in a bit. Just woke up so kinda groggy.

Though going into today, I was thinking that Max, Space, Caps, and Ex were a good group to look into for how d2 ended.

Twice now Max has been tied for a leading wagon (though d1 wasn't as obvious because of the missed vote). I feel his flip could be telling. Ex was also one of the tied wagons d2 too. So if either of those two are scum than mafia could've tried saving them by placing the third vote on Pikochu. Which is where Space comes in.

And Caps is more because I'm a bit paranoid about him. I've felt good about pretty much everything he's said, but I felt good about him for a while when he was scum in the crossover game as well. And I felt kinda paranoid that scum might have a rolecop and copped Pikochu to find out he was vig, and decided to push his lynch because of it. Plus, I agree with Jinjo that the n1 kill looks like a vetern kill.
 
Minish said:
Wait, roleblocker doesn't block kills for you all usually do they? Because they do on zd.
Click to expand...
They don't here, but Funnier isn't from bulbagarden, he's from ZD.

My role looks like a bulbagarden style role, plain and simple (And miller is very common here)... So I'll have to rely on the rest of you, but does anyone feel like their roles are more ZD than bulba?

If funnier is using the zd roles, then it is possible roleblocker does protect from killers too.

Vote: Max

I'm sorry Max, but you've acted even more suspicious than is normal for you, and your claim (Bulletproof on your own) sounds weird.
 
AussieEevee said:
They don't here, but Funnier isn't from bulbagarden, he's from ZD.

My role looks like a bulbagarden style role, plain and simple (And miller is very common here)... So I'll have to rely on the rest of you, but does anyone feel like their roles are more ZD than bulba?

If funnier is using the zd roles, then it is possible roleblocker does protect from killers too.

Vote: Max

I'm sorry Max, but you've acted even more suspicious than is normal for you, and your claim (Bulletproof on your own) sounds weird.
Click to expand...


Yeah, that's why I was a bit confused everyone assumed it was automatically the doctor who blocked the kill. Then I remembered you all don't have roleblockers block kills like we do. But at least now if there is a town roleblocker they can know they may have stopped it.

I feel pretty certain funnier would make roleblocker block kills here as well.

Also, bulletproof on it's own isn't that strange to me. But that's not saying anything on how Max has been playing. I feel like his flip could be telling, but I also feel like he's probably easy mislynch bait for mafia to push if he is town.
 
Minish said:
Or there's a town roleblocker...
Wait, roleblocker doesn't block kills for you all usually do they? Because they do on zd.
Click to expand...
From what I've seen sometimes they do, sometimes they don't, depends on the hosts.

But I feel like if Roleblocker stops kills that would throw even more protective roles into the balance, which is kinda insane. According to the claims and common sense there would be a Bodyguard, a Bulletproof, a Doctor, and a Roleblocker. Not to mention the Bus Driver shenanigans that could redirect the kill to the bulletproof, another scum, or even turn a possible scum roleblocker in another Town protection.

I can imagine a setup like that hapening if mafia had an unlimited strongman, but of that's the case why would they not use it and not risk getting doctored/roleblocked?
 
*to not risk getting doctored/roleblocked

Was that a softclaim, Minish? Why didn't you even consider Jailer, which is a more common town role? If that was I feel you should straight up out yourself and share with us who did you target last night so we can filter today's lynch more.

If you're the roleblocker I'd assume both Backset and Max are lying because of the excessive ammount of protective roles around. But if we're going to consider someone else got stopped we might as well start pressing them.

@BackSet, would you mind sharing a readlist?
@DekuNut, do you have any info or theories to share?
 
Paranoia is attacking me again and I just realized there could be a poisoner :confused:
That could also explain why there were no Night Kills right?
If that was a Poisoner Kill are we in MyLo? :confused:
 
ExLight said:
Was that a softclaim, Minish?
Click to expand...

Nope. If it were I would've been voting for whoever I roleblocked. I was just letting a town roleblocker (if there is one) know they could roleblock the kill.

Also town roleblocker is a thousand times more common than jailer on zd. That's why I went to that thought and not jailer.

They can also be disadvantageous for town since that means they can also block town. So they're not super protective roles. Also bodyguard dies when they protect still. So in theory bulletproof/bodyguard/roleblocker isn't impossible to be all town to me.
 
ExLight said:
Paranoia is attacking me again and I just realized there could be a poisoner :confused:
That could also explain why there were no Night Kills right?
If that was a Poisoner Kill are we in MyLo? :confused:
Click to expand...
Poisoner seems very unlikely to me, as only one character in the games really fits that role... and I doubt she'd have such a boring role.
 
AussieEevee said:
Poisoner seems very unlikely to me, as only one character in the games really fits that role... and I doubt she'd have such a boring role.
Click to expand...
THE character, and its a really remarkable part of it

and it makes sense balance wise since it can be scum's kill modifier that ignores protection

Don't dismiss the possibility just because it is "Boring" :confused:
 
Would a poisoner be independent or mafia?

I'm not sure how it works on a forum, but I thought on epicmafia that if someone was poisoned, they would be notified of it.
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom