Mafia Chaos Mafia: Day 8 - American Bad

[Zexy]

Vivuto's not posting would have been a good move, actually, if he was around to place kills.

Of course although posting KILL: <target> isn't harmful, all you would see is KILL: <redacted>
Not posting could imply him sending the kill to Flop via PM, or just that the last scum was inactive which was the case...

 

[HumanDawn]

Damn, I was rooting for the Town to win this. It's a shame the Town lost the way it did with so many misplays after such a good streak. I thought TheProtobabe was Mafia too.

 

[Qing'e]

The funny thing is, Pitou was the character I chose, and I thought of a few roles I would give it, all of which would have been noticeably more useful for scum than Bodyguard ^^;

 

[Zexy]

The funny thing is, Pitou was the character I chose,

I was pretty sure. You can at least brag that your character won the game.
I was also pretty sure that Squidward = Life.

 

[TheProtobabe]

The funny thing is, Pitou was the character I chose, and I thought of a few roles I would give it, all of which would have been noticeably more useful for scum than Bodyguard ^^;

Neferpitou is an amazing character. <333

Also, who picked Hisoka? I actually was gonna send in Killua, but was told to pick someone else so I did Natsu. WHERE MY HXH HOMIES AT

 

[lovandra]

This game is simply chaotic. I though Mafia is UP but since we gathered so many items, it saved us at the end I guess. This game is actually easy to read but town simply, chaos and paranoid till the end.

Honestly, this remind me to Red Dwarf Mafia... when actually town was do pretty well till the last end....

 

[Life]

Well, if I'm being honest I have to say that I'm pretty sour I lost due to RNG when I was almost guaranteed to be lynched the next day. But oh well, I had a lot fun playing as an independent, and even though I've been playing mafia for more than a year I've never gotten to be an indep (except in indep mafia where everyone was an independent...), so this was an exciting first.

The game was even more fun though when the whole issue with Serial Killer came about. That was just a random guess by me but it ended up being true. I was really surprised to find there was another indep, and after Zexy and co. were posting 'please reveal yourself indep' all I could think was if they were talking about me or not and I was like "omg how awkward would it be if i was like 'OKAY its me guys' and they totally didn't mean me". Obviously I didn't do that.

anyway, questions !

Did you all enjoy the game?

Very much so! Had I played as town I think it would have made this game a lot different for me, but playing as an indep was really fun/interesting, and I'm happy the RNG chose me for that though apparently the RNG gods have some karma issues i guess

Was I an OK host?

Indeed, I believed so. I've played another game by you in the past and I find that you're a pretty efficient/thorough host, Flop, which is great.

Was it balanced?

I believe so, but I'm not an expert host so I can't say much.

Would you play the setup again?

Of course!

Thank you for hosting and letting me play, Flop! Really enjoyed it!

also do you know how RIDICULOUSLY HARD it is to write in only six-letter words??? dear lord.

I can relate. In a past game where everyone had post-restrictions, mine was that I could only use 7-letter words in my posts. It was painful, not going to lie. Managed to get through by remembering long words and just bolding what I meant.




edit: forgot to mention that yes squidward was definitely me. He's one of (if not my favorite) characters throughout all media, to be honest.

 

[TheCapsFan]

Thank you for hosting such a great game Flop! I had a lot of fun, and you were fantastic at hosting. My favorite part was Protobabe's restriction; the first time I saw that I actually physically laughed.

It never once crossed my mind that the triple sub could be mafia. I thought it was Proto. :/ I'd say I did like, the least for town, since I made so many mistakes, but I'll ask for an evaluation anyway.

 

[Maniacal Engineer]

@Flopunny; let's host a mafia game together some time. I like your style!

 

[Snowy]

also do you know how RIDICULOUSLY HARD it is to write in only six-letter words??? dear lord.

You think that's hard? It was even harder to read it

Which is my fault. The item I used on you must have caused the restriction

*Screams* I kind of thought Aussie may have been Mafia, but I thought Proto was the most likeliest. *Sigh* It was truly chaotic.

It was very chaotic... and hard for me as it is my first go at a proper mafia game and I was on my own, with no way to get advice.

Still, good game to both of you.

Paranoia really kicked in at the end. Logic was totally out of the window with everyone accusing the cops. Well, at least we won't do that again. Aussie is truly cunning.

Well, I dunno if I'd go that far...

Dead QT reading!

I mean, Jaina has brushed the dark side but she's never fallen to the darkside...

Jaina Proudmoore?!

Solo. Jaina Solo. My character was a Jedi Master, which is why the vanilla role confused me

But come to think of it, that quote can apply to Jaina proudmoore as she has also "Brushed the darkside" since her home city was destroyed.

Also, I'll note that Eevee might have been lynched if Sword had checked him. What happened the last night?

Checking me wouldn't have helped. I had an item that granted me godfather powers.

Damn, I was rooting for the Town to win this. It's a shame the Town lost the way it did with so many misplays after such a good streak. I thought TheProtobabe was Mafia too.

I thought @Sword Master; was scum on my first go and thought that right up until I subbed in. When Flop told me she was subbing me in, I expected to get a town role and that SM was the last mafia xD
@Flopunny;:

Did I enjoy the game?
Yes and No. I did on my second go, but I got eliminated far too early on my first go! Damn you, @Zexy; or whoever put in that nightkill.

Were you an okay host?
Absolutely. I have no complaints.

Balance?
I have no complaints about Balance, but then again, I'm not exactly experienced enough to judge it.

It was disappointing that Jaina got vanilla, but I understand that you needed to balance out the town's roles.

Would I play this set up again?
Absolutely! How soon can you have Chaos 2 set up?

Items?
That mask that granted godfather powers was just so evil. If it wasn't for that, I might have had to decide between Rabbit and SM on the nightkill. But because of that, SM was like a vanilla in my eyes.

My biggest threat, as I said in the QT, was Rabbit... and it helped me when Proto direct addressed Rabbit right before the night kill. I'm sure I could have played that fact even better than I do xD

I must admit, I had thought about making a fake conversation to try and convince rabbit that SM and proto were mafia, but I made the mistake of asking Flop if I was the last mafia left. I'm also not 100% sure I could have imitated their posting styles enough to convince you, @Rabbit;.

Good game everyone.

 

[Doctor Floptopus]

I'm actually really surprised that no one thought of the possibility of a godfather item. I mean, there was even a false ID as a hypothetical example in the OP!

 

[Sword Master]

I chose @Rabbit;'s character. I hope he had fun with it. This is the best mafia game I ever played, but in hindsight I could've done other decisions which could've helped us win.

 

[Feenie]

Good game, congratulations mafia! Thank you Flopunny for hosting!

Did you all enjoy the game?
I thought the game was a lot of fun, I really enjoyed playing it. I liked the mechanics and the whole very very confusing cop thing we had going on there. I thought that was really enjoyable in a chaotic sort of way.

Was I an OK host?
Definitely! I thought you were a good host, I don't have any complaints.

Was it balanced?
I'm not the best person to ask for this type of thing, but it appeared pretty balanced to me?

Would you play the setup again?
For sure, I can't resist a Chaos Mafia 2.

Also, this is probably maybe obvious but the character I chose was Phoenix Wright. I've never played Mario & Luigi: Dream Team but Prince Dreambert is cute, so I was happy with who I got-- although I wouldn't have minded getting one of the HxH characters.

 

[Snowy]

Speaking of which, how the heck did I end up with my own character? I chose Jaina, I got Jaina! I was happy!

 

[Doctor Floptopus]

Speaking of which, how the heck did I end up with my own character? I chose Jaina, I got Jaina! I was happy!

Random.org told me to...

 

[ReturnofMCH]

GG everyone.
I told you before zexy... if you were scum... turns out you were
I wish I didn't get angry though.

 

[Sword Master]

About the dominion rod I kinda used it on Progress role to kill Momoka (sorry), and then I used it to check Kyraki (who I found suspicious because of the post restriction).

 

[jackatlasred]

Gg mafia, you had us all fooled there.

Overall I though it was a nice game. I also suspected kyriaki and that would pod been my next check if I had one. I though it was kinda suspicious when she defended blissey.

Anyways gg ky and vi and ev. Seriously a triple sub...

 

[Snowy]

Anyways gg ky and vi and ev. Seriously a triple sub...

If Viv had been posting in the QT, I'm pretty sure the game would have been over as Rabbit would have picked up on the three changes in posting style xD

Speaking of which, how the heck did I end up with my own character? I chose Jaina, I got Jaina! I was happy!

Random.org told me to...

The Force had to have been with me. Because the odds of that happening would be pretty low

 

[Zexy]

Spoiler

Did I enjoy the game?
Yes and No. I did on my second go, but I got eliminated far too early on my first go! Damn you, @Zexy; or whoever put in that nightkill.

Come on, buddy, had I not done that you wouldn't have become the one who won the game in the first place!

I'm actually really surprised that no one thought of the possibility of a godfather item. I mean, there was even a false ID as a hypothetical example in the OP!

Oh, I thought that was lovandra's original idea. Anyways, I would expect it if there was only cop (but again I wouldn't care since I would be that cop, or so I thought early on). Upon realizing that there were 4 cops with sanities I thought there wouldn't be much point in such an item.

Good game, congratulations mafia! Thank you Flopunny for hosting!

Did you all enjoy the game?
I thought the game was a lot of fun, I really enjoyed playing it. I liked the mechanics and the whole very very confusing cop thing we had going on there. I thought that was really enjoyable in a chaotic sort of way.

Momoka, you thought you could trust me?

I told you before zexy... if you were scum... turns out you were

That was a nice item you gave me there. Although in the end it didn't get used much.

About the dominion rod I kinda used it on Progress role to kill Momoka (sorry), and then I used it to check Kyraki (who I found suspicious because of the post restriction).

OH WOW THANKS
I didn't get to use it to kill a townie... but you did it for me! This is a little minus in your rating I gave you in the VM (since you picked one more wrong target) but still.
Too bad you didn't keep your suspicion on Kyriaki...

The Force had to have been with me. Because the odds of that happening would be pretty low

1/19