I just believe that Max needs to come out and explain his actions since they seem distrustful. I feel like he is just trying to find anyone to accuse without much evidence, meaning he could either be mafia trying to put the blame on someone else or a very jumpy town member. However I believe that he is leaning more to the former.
His responses just seem so unsure and supsicious to me.
I actually am the latter.
Is that your only response? You have no other defense at all?
I don't want to claim, because it wouldn't end well for Town if I do.
I have to admit that being a bit jumpy and flip-flopping is consistent with how Max tends to play, but this is somewhat excessive even for him.
I've gotta agree with swarla Max, you get called out and this is your only response?
Honestly, at this point it's not gonna end well for you if you don't. I know that there are legitimately good reasons to avoid a claim, but unless some other info comes to light you're probably our best bet today.
Bodyguard? I don't believe I'm familiar with this role. Is it a variant on doctor? Is there anything you can do that's different from your standard doc?
I protect someone at the cost of my own life. Now do you see why I said it'd be bad for Town if I claimed?
The PM doesn't clarify it.
I just got clarification from Elementar: I die only if me or the target is shot.
I think we should give him the benefit of doubt. What he's saying here lines up perfectly with Butler. Artemis' bodyguard.
I love how both you and Zexy are on my case instead of doing anything yourselves. And I don't have a choice but to do anything in mid phase because I subbed in midphase. D1 was mostly inactive save for me and Darth. D2 has been mostly inactive save for Max and Zexy. And max doesn't strike me as scum action wise because unlike most of the thread he tried something. And now you're voting me for voting you? Honestly your response makes me feel you as more likely scum.
I wouldn't worry too much about it. Independent claims always stand out, we now know that DarthWolf13 isn't town. We can always revisit it later, but thinking too much about it now isn't going to help, even if he is scum; we won't really be lynching him today so we'd rather focus on other people.
While I agree with the logic I don't think it is enough for a vote on her right away; she hasn't even said much, this reads more like an OMGUS than a legit case.
Any chance you could say a bit more yourself, actually
Scum don't always jump on easy lynches, especially in this somewhat quiet game I feel like doing so too much would be too obvious. I'd like to hear more from you too, I feel like you're not saying much here, just somewhat restating what others did.
Yeah he was actually suspected for a good chunk of Sun/Moon Mafia because of that.
"If Max is telling the truth there's no way he could be scum", while true, is one of the most pointless things to say.
Claims don't always explain previous scummy behaviour, but they are still more valid than reads so we just need to think less about reads and more about concrete info. Town can make scummy posts more easily than scum can claim towny roles and get away with it, after all. So yes we're giving him the benefit of the doubt.
This sounds very scummy. It's easy to say that we just need to lynch someone else but be passive about it until the end of the phase. And while I understand that you may indeed have to go sleep, it also is too good of an excuse.
I wasn't on your case, just asked one thing about your first post after coming back because it was strange. And while I still don't like that you haven't done anything scummy since.
Also "Zexy posts" has become a thing now? Heh.
My role in this game is rather important. That's why I definitely don't want to get mislynched.
While it is important, what it does is having you killed instead of someone else; that's not TOO strong imho.
