- Joined
- Aug 9, 2016
- Messages
- 8,113
- Reaction score
- 24,606
I suspect this was partly due to Black and White... with Gen 4, FireRed/LeafGreen and HeartGold/SoulSilver meant that Gens 1-3 were all very recent and nothing was unobtainable. But then Gen 5 basically chucked all of the old pokemon out and then proceeded to not have a remake, so Gen 6 and 7 had to compensate a bit because suddenly everything but Gen 3 was several years old again. It seems to me that they do a decent job of not requiring anyone to get a really old game to get a pokemon, so incorporating a lot of old pokemon into a region is probably a necessary thing, especially with the large gap that was Gen 5.I feel like the lower amount of pokemon isn't even really a big issue, the way they're distributed among older pokemon in the region is.
I've been replaying platinum lately and I've noticed that while if you exlude the evolutions of previous gen mons, sinnoh's dex isn't really big at all. Despite this, you're mostly encountering only sinnoh mons throughout t he game (or least early on) which while there isn't this massive amount of new pokemon, there's certainly the illusion of it.
Meanwhile in alola a lot of the new pokemon are legitimately elusive and you tend to encounter old gen pokemon quite frequently. It feels mostly old with a sprinkle of new rather than a completely new experience. I hope this is something taken into consideration in gen 8
Maybe they could do it better, though? Instead of overloading them throughout the region, they could sprinkle a few here and there and just add a huge safari zone each game to cover what's missing.