HumanDawn
Living the rich life
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2011
- Messages
- 7,713
- Reaction score
- 3,464
@Kender & @Malevolent I feel like Felly should be ignored right now. If they have an immunity to votes and being killed, it might be a temporary one that only lasts a few phases. I think there was a role that was immune to death until the end of N2 in another game, but I am completely blanking out which game that was. Were you told that your action failed?
I agree that there should be at least one vote on her because of the mid-day votes to see if it's still active.
Cyanide's vote on Malevolent makes sense.
That's true, but none of us knew about all votes being nullified. If I knew of Felly's ability, my change of vote (Cyanide ->Felly) would have changed from a No Lynch... to a No Lynch... The only reason we got a lynch is because Lone_Garurumon unvoted in the last few minutes... I don't think I could predict that would happen? Yeah, Lone_Garurumon wasn't able to shift the lynch, but he isn't the only player in the game, and anyone can vote somebody else if they wanted, which a lot of player like MegaPod and Officer Snake, and... even you, didn't do.
Also, you put attention on her before I did, and I remember first criticizing the wagon you placed the third vote on. If I wanted to waste the Town's Day, why would I even bother? We don't know if Kender's role is actually wasted anyway, Kender wasn't necessarily going to use her vig N1.
I agree that there should be at least one vote on her because of the mid-day votes to see if it's still active.
Cyanide's vote on Malevolent makes sense.
Any specific reason for this?
MegaPod posted a suspicion but ended the day without a vote. He posted a concern, to which I answered, and he didn’t act.
LG's lynch is somewhat his fault, so that makes things a bit more awkward and hard to work with since he could've placed his vote on someone else so the Day phase didn't end with a mislynch. Because of that I feel like we didn't get a decent amount of info about the wagonomics. I'm still going to give it a second read, but at first the only thing that struck me as weird was HD moving his vote, which made it impossible for LG to shift the lynch to someone else after Unvoting himself.
Did anyone else target Felly last night? We might be able to know if she's some kind of commuter.
For now I think I'll vote HD, I'm not exactly fond of his arguments, and if he knew actions would fail on her, then most of D1 could've been somewhat attracting attention to her to waste town roles.
Vote: HumanDawn
It's not a big wagon for now, so I don't see any problems with that.
That's true, but none of us knew about all votes being nullified. If I knew of Felly's ability, my change of vote (Cyanide ->Felly) would have changed from a No Lynch... to a No Lynch... The only reason we got a lynch is because Lone_Garurumon unvoted in the last few minutes... I don't think I could predict that would happen? Yeah, Lone_Garurumon wasn't able to shift the lynch, but he isn't the only player in the game, and anyone can vote somebody else if they wanted, which a lot of player like MegaPod and Officer Snake, and... even you, didn't do.
Also, you put attention on her before I did, and I remember first criticizing the wagon you placed the third vote on. If I wanted to waste the Town's Day, why would I even bother? We don't know if Kender's role is actually wasted anyway, Kender wasn't necessarily going to use her vig N1.