Ghostsoul
"You can order me around and I'll disappoint you!"
- Joined
- May 25, 2015
- Messages
- 480
- Reaction score
- 188
A general statement. Not positive or negative.Is this criticism on the characterization? A compliment on it? Just a toneless remark? I can't tell what you're trying to say with this. Keep in mind that this literally begins your entire post, so I have nothing to compare this with.
Oh, that sentence was more a jokeYou were frustrated by something enough to all-caps your comment, as if you were shouting at a movie screen from the middle of the theater? Chill, my man.
Whoops.
It's really, just how I would have personally written it. If your focus is how 'out of the blue' you want everything to seem, it's mostly your choice.Why would someone in a semi-lucid dream waste time in a transformation sequence - and add pain, which is typically pretty undesirable - when they know they can do it much faster and strike completely out of the blue to the horror of everyone? A transition from man to giant monster isn't very divine if it takes time and appears possible through other means. Would Genesis of the Bible have really appeared that impressive if God had created the world in millennia instead of mere days?
Again, the god comment was a joke.I'm very confused. Before, you tell him to hurry up and become a god, now you want him to take his sweet time with the mayhem?
The 'sweet time' thing, however, wasn't.
Not enough interesting shock. There is generally, a good amount of shock, but some of it is a bit typical or bland, for my taste anyway.Is my fic too much shock, just the right amount of shock, or not shock enough in your opinion? I seriously cannot tell.
By setting I meant general atmosphere and tone. Right now the audience doesn't have much to root for and therefore not too much of a reason to read...Setting? Likable?
Oh, totally. It was just the feeling I got that some aspects may have tied to either a kind of wish fulfillment or sense of catharsis you get from writing this out. Which is totally fine but can sometimes lead itself to some bad writing when done poorly. You seem to be getting some things write in this aspect at least in this regard.Where are you getting this? You do know me and my character are separate, right?
Perhaps because I'm unclear with the (sub)genre you are going for? Splatter/Shock horror was just the genre I assumed you were going for. There may be aspects of other genres within the fic (like psychological, cosmic or thriller) but they aren't all that clear from what I've read myself so far.Thank you for calling my fic pointless shock, very encouraging.
I agree with you that this review was kind of mean. I apologize for that.The author ends up feeling pretty discouraged.