- Joined
- Jan 2, 2010
- Messages
- 7,283
- Reaction score
- 3,153
I knew I should have gone with something else! Yeah, looking back, that scene was stupid.
I wouldn't quite go that far. You've already got the theme running that parents aren't perfect, for one thing.
Anyway, at fifteen chapters in - well, more or less - it seems appropriate to do another reflection review.
First thing I thought about was what keeps bringing me back to the story. I'm pretty sure you know by now that if I don't like a story, I don't torture myself by reading further and posting constant complaining reviews (I just drop it). The conclusion I ended up at was that, for all the things I could pick out that need improvement, I can see that you're trying. That rather looks patronising now I've typed it, though I don't intend it to be. I mean that in a fandom characterised by endless stories about essentially the same thing, you're trying to do something different. Looking at my list of regular reads, that's pretty much the common thread that links them all.
In my notes I have a few questioning thoughts about tone and the logic of the plot for each chapter. Most of them I didn't end up posting, because, well, most of them are really grey areas and I also didn't want the reviews to be nothing but a round of picking. If I were a beta reader, I might have a different approach ... in any case, I'm also conscious that you have a lot of readers who seem to expect the story to be very karmically correct according to their own moral code. I've never had to reconcile that with taking criticism constructively, so it doesn't seem appropriate for me to keep picking in light of that.
So what can I say. Well. As far as style is concerned, your prose is consistently ok. There are a few conventions I'm not a huge fan of - the viewpoint bounces around a bit, bracketing translations of poké-speak, etc - but not what I'd call a huge deal. A lot of the emotion is rather bluntly written, but then I seem to recall that you have difficulty in getting the nuances down so I've got more - what's the word? Patience, maybe? - for it than I would usually have. I think it's in the description and general scene setting that there's most room for improvement. That's where research is your friend. I mentioned before how nouns can save you a lot of trouble. I'd also say that looking at photographs of the sort of thing you're trying to describe is a neat trick as well.
The one thing I will come back to is pacing. As I type this I'm actually most of the way through Chapter 15, and good heavens, what a monster that is. I did a quick word count - that's 11,000 words for a chapter full of four battles and two subplots. There's really three chapters in that. And a lot of fat to trim as well - I think you were probably aware that four battles against Morty over two chapters would get tiresome, which accounts for why Casieal wins so easily (Not a huge problem, that, I don't mind Gym battles playing out a little differently). Really though, apart from him getting his Fog Badge, the battle itself doesn't have a lot of story in it. You could have started the chapter in media res with Casieal winning, and moved right on to Julia's fight with Morty in the immediate aftermath.
I'm not certain, but I suspect this is possibly down to little planning of the pacing of the arc. It might help to think of the arc as a mini-story. Where do you want to the climax to be? How quickly do you want to build to it, and how do you want the cooldown to go afterwards? Each chapter is a self-contained story, so you can play with that to work in your favour. The climax of the arc will usually have more impact if it's contained within it's own chapter with nothing else. You can surprise the reader with a sudden speeding up of plot that doesn't resolve until the next chapter. In the end you'll probably find this is easier on yourself since you won't be worrying so much about whether to shunt something into a .5 chapter at the last minute
Ok, that was longer than expected, so I think I'll end there