- Joined
- Oct 18, 2011
- Messages
- 5,558
- Reaction score
- 1,821
- Pronouns
- She/Her
- Any
Nice work on the lynch! Now that I'm free from worrying about the dentist, I should be a little more in the right mindset to actually be active lol. no cavities
Kyriaki was the first vote on MCH (I think? I don't remember seeing one before that vote) and it wasn't a vote framed as a joke or a gentle prodding between scumbuddies imo, so I'm thinking Kyriaki is looking pretty good right now on that basis.
Knowing now that Max is almost assuredly town, part of me finds MegaPod's vote on Max interesting just for the fact that I absolutely could see scum wanting to take advantage of a misspoken comment like Max's knowing that he tends to be easy to incriminate with stuff like that and it could've been a smooth mislynch (and in fact may have happened that way had he not made his softclaim clear just in time). This kinda goes for Pika_pika as well. I get where their votes were coming from and it's good that they both provided reasoning and continued to question Max (and both did unvote once the claim came to light), but it does make me wonder. It's "interesting" in not necessarily a "SCUM!" way but a "not sure if I'm just paranoid or if I should keep this in the back of my mind going forward" kind of way.
That said, the later votes on Max are a bit worse, like jd's that pretty much rode MP's coattails in reasoning, and he didn't add much else the rest of the phase. I don't even remember seeing Space's vote while rereading, which isn't a good sign either since that likely means it didn't add much. Feenie's is a little better since she generally contributed more as a whole that phase than some of the other Max voters. The Light's vote was also bad, but I do remember that sometimes even as town he tends to make posts that kinda seem scummy with sheeping so I need to see more to get a better idea there, though his recent posts on this page actually seem genuine to me and not jumpy about being seen as suspicious, which is a good look. I think that was all the Max voters?
Officer Snake I'm so far reading as town; his vote on MCH was quite good in providing reasoning for it and building a case further, so I'm reading it as legitimate and not a very early bussing attempt.
Ereshkigal I'm seeing mentioned for the joking around and some other stuff, but I'm pretty sure I remember Ereshkigal getting into some hot water over similar jokes in past games way back, so it's not really alignment indicative to me so far.
Crystal Onix looks decent so far, I'd lean town since coming forth about the Nexus claim rather than letting potential chaos ensue from the nexus role feels like a pro-town action, since scum I feel like would rather let us get confused by it eventually, assuming the claim is legit.
Everyone else I need to look at more closely after a legit reread rather than the skim that I did to catch up.
Kyriaki was the first vote on MCH (I think? I don't remember seeing one before that vote) and it wasn't a vote framed as a joke or a gentle prodding between scumbuddies imo, so I'm thinking Kyriaki is looking pretty good right now on that basis.
Knowing now that Max is almost assuredly town, part of me finds MegaPod's vote on Max interesting just for the fact that I absolutely could see scum wanting to take advantage of a misspoken comment like Max's knowing that he tends to be easy to incriminate with stuff like that and it could've been a smooth mislynch (and in fact may have happened that way had he not made his softclaim clear just in time). This kinda goes for Pika_pika as well. I get where their votes were coming from and it's good that they both provided reasoning and continued to question Max (and both did unvote once the claim came to light), but it does make me wonder. It's "interesting" in not necessarily a "SCUM!" way but a "not sure if I'm just paranoid or if I should keep this in the back of my mind going forward" kind of way.
That said, the later votes on Max are a bit worse, like jd's that pretty much rode MP's coattails in reasoning, and he didn't add much else the rest of the phase. I don't even remember seeing Space's vote while rereading, which isn't a good sign either since that likely means it didn't add much. Feenie's is a little better since she generally contributed more as a whole that phase than some of the other Max voters. The Light's vote was also bad, but I do remember that sometimes even as town he tends to make posts that kinda seem scummy with sheeping so I need to see more to get a better idea there, though his recent posts on this page actually seem genuine to me and not jumpy about being seen as suspicious, which is a good look. I think that was all the Max voters?
Officer Snake I'm so far reading as town; his vote on MCH was quite good in providing reasoning for it and building a case further, so I'm reading it as legitimate and not a very early bussing attempt.
Ereshkigal I'm seeing mentioned for the joking around and some other stuff, but I'm pretty sure I remember Ereshkigal getting into some hot water over similar jokes in past games way back, so it's not really alignment indicative to me so far.
Crystal Onix looks decent so far, I'd lean town since coming forth about the Nexus claim rather than letting potential chaos ensue from the nexus role feels like a pro-town action, since scum I feel like would rather let us get confused by it eventually, assuming the claim is legit.
Everyone else I need to look at more closely after a legit reread rather than the skim that I did to catch up.