Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I'm going to laugh so hard if anyone votes Infernape. That monkey's just too badass.
Totodile because I don't think Ash deserved it.
May I just ask how Ash didn't not deserve Totodile?
May I just ask how Ash didn't not deserve Totodile?
I realize that Totodile wasn't really used that much...Not much for any of his major matches anyways....I disagree with the decision to let Ash have Totodile...it would've been better off with Misty...
Ash hasn't really called on it since he caught it for major matches, and at least with Misty it probably would be a Feraligatr by now so...
It would just have been neglected like the rest of her Pokémon, and thus would receive a huge decrease in both screen-time as well as battles.
It wouldn't have been a Feraligatr, it would just have been a weaker Totodile.
Sure there were some neglected like Goldeen & Horsea but saying that ALL her pokemon were neglected is NOT true.
Right, your opinion on the matter. When Ash's three starters in Johto ended up as a fiasco as we got to see. With Misty as Water Specialist, Totodile would have be under better care and long term looking benefit more from training and battling in the Cerulean Gym compared to the case at Prof.Oaks lab where he is being wasted.
Not Psyduck,
So, the relationship is a key factor too, and I'm not saying that the relationship between Misty and Totodile would've been bad, but I definitely can't see it becoming better than the relationship Ash is having with his Pokémon.
And please, don't take up completely irrelevant stuff as what Misty is doing in the presence, because that has nothing to do with how Totodile would've been treated in Johto.
Or Corsola, Poliwhirl/Politoed & Staryu.
Well I think it would have been better with her, they were a good combination
and Ash has TOO MANY pokemon so I can't see how it's relationship would have been better with him.
Misty has less pokemon than him so I can see it being treated better. And please, don't try to disprove what I think because it's my opinion.
Well I decided to mention it, because right now Totodile isn't being treated well AT ALL under Ash's care.
And all those battles you aforementioned Totodile lost A LOT of them. The fact that Cyndaquil & Chikorita evolved and not Totodile says enough it self.
You honestly think that Totodile would've received more battles and experience if he belonged to Misty? How?
Even though it's true that Totodile didn't participate in the same amount of battles like Ash's Cyndaquil did, he still was frequently used lots of times through out the saga. He battled against Seel, Seaking, Poliwhirl, Charizard, Sneasel/Hypno, Slugma/Electabuzz, Miltank, Lanturn, Ditto and Rhydon, and surely did he battle others too, but naturally I can't remember them all.
The point is, that's like more battles than Misty has ever participated in herself in Johto, so why would it be different if Misty had caught it? It would just have been neglected like the rest of her Pokémon, and thus would receive a huge decrease in both screen-time as well as battles. It wouldn't have been a Feraligatr, it would just have been a weaker Totodile.
In comparison with the treatment Ash's Pokémon received in Johto, yes. Not Psyduck, though.
Poliwag line, Staryu and Corsdola got generally more screen time than Totodile did.
Definitely not better than the duo of Ash and Totodile, not to mention that I'm not even able to recall Misty and Totodile interacting.
Misty was incredibly excited about Totodile fan girling all over it, im sure his enthusiasm would work quite well with her eager and quirky personality.
[QUOTEG
How? With the addition of Totodile in his team, he had six Pokémon. How was that too many Pokémon?
I'm not trying to convince you to chance opinion, I'm just stating what I think regarding the matter. And Misty really didn't have less Pokémon. She had Togepi, Palpitoed, Corsola, Staryu, Psyduck and Goldeen, and while a few of them were neglected during Johto none of Ash's Pokémon were neglected during the Johto saga. Right?