HumanDawn
Living the rich life
- Joined
- Sep 19, 2011
- Messages
- 7,713
- Reaction score
- 3,464
Town would be ExLight and surprisingly Rainbow Cloud now. ExLight I thought was a little shaky at the beginning of D1 with mostly just clarification posts (like quoting what pocketing meant when Luminary asked), but I like that Ex comes in and asks useful questions without too much fluff attached (like asides in the questions that would be filler). Once ExLight got going about mid D1-ish, I haven't really been pinged by them. Rainbow Cloud is in large part due to the claim; I know RC is a Sonic fan and thus could make up a fakeclaim that could feel legit, but that claim has been corroborated by TheCapsFan, and I don't think scum would want to buddy that obviously if they were BOTH scum trying to make an airtight fakeclaim. It also does fit a character pretty well IMO (Silver is my guess there), and RC's response to both my suspicions on him and his recent posts have been solid. His point about Pikochu (as well as Human's comment about his problem with the Deku vote) is a very good one. Human and Jinjo would probably be my next highest townreads.
Glad we're on the same wavelength there - but why the Town reads on me and... Jinjo??
Scum is Tood (especially with the survivor claim and no other ability attached to it; this has not made my scumread lessened at all, let's put it that way) and kind of a tie of ZinnLav (really for what they've inherited from DawningWinds, which has been addressed enough, but going from actually bothering to make a post for a late vote D1 to then subbing out presumably by request given it's mid-phase with no prior indication of wanting to do that is timing that also makes me nervous) and Pikochu, who I absolutely see the case against from RC and he really does feel disconnected from a lot of the events of the game, to the extent that he's probably the player I've most forgotten was in this game.
How do you feel about him saying he's simply survivor and nothing else?
The claim looks really bad as just a Survivor... Like, I find it hard to believe that Lone_Garurumon would make the game have bastard elements and just make Tood a plain old Survivor. In that case, I would mind even less if he got lynched, but I feel like his behaviour just comes off as a third party who doesn't care about what's going on. I feel like scum would make more of an effort to pretend to give a damn about the game. Is there anyone that would fit Survivor at least?
But aside from when the Pika_pika topic has come up, I really don't think Midorikawa has been that aggressive in this game? Just going off memory, it feels like most of her posts this phase have revolved around this single topic, with just a few things I can remember related to other players (she commented on the Jinjo votes).
Hmm...
Yeah, you're right about Pika_Pika42 - She hasn't really questioned that many other players despite being active. She says it's because of her work, but then she still only uses the activity she has to focus on Pika_Pika42. The thing about her aggression is that it feels like it makes sense for town!Mido to sometimes be narrow-minded to make hasty conclusions like saying Pika MUST either be Mafia or Independent. I might be getting it mixed up with scum her doing it, but I'm leaning on her just being narrow-minded for now.
I'm with you here, especially with him claiming that survivor is the only thing he is. No other ability being attached to it seems unlikely, especially when we've seen some wild claims so far from Pika and RC, and if Pika is truthful, there have been two potential killing roles already (his and Zorchic). Survivor not having anything to help survive...? Unvoting and then not voting anyone else doesn't help either.
Good point about them having nothing helping them to survive.